Foucault's History of Sexuality: Biopower and the Construction of Sex
In the first volume of The History of Sexuality, Michel Foucault examines how prohibitions, confession, and biopower shaped sexuality as an object of knowledge.
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Power, discourse, and sexuality › When speaking is part of the problemFull chapter · Sections in this chapter1 / 7 ↓
When speaking is part of the problem
A school tells its pupils to be discreet about sex. Its teachers and doctors may also write instructions about where the pupils sleep, where they can be alone, and who should question them if a particular habit is suspected. If we look only for what the pupils are forbidden to say, the school can appear quiet on the subject. Look at what adults are required to observe, describe, and record, and the picture changes. In the first volume of The History of Sexuality, Michel Foucault uses examples of this kind to ask what a history of sexual silence leaves out. Foucault, The History of Sexuality, vol. I, part II.
The book appeared in French in 1976 and in Robert Hurley's English translation in 1978. It treats sexuality as an object that became available to particular forms of inquiry and intervention. Behaviors can be investigated, linked to a case history, and treated as evidence of a person's character. The institutions that investigate them help establish what is worth knowing and who can speak with authority. Tracing those relations gives Foucault a way to understand the interest in sexual truth alongside prohibitions that could be severe. The History of Sexuality, vol. I, parts I–III.
What the repressive hypothesis says
Foucault opens with a familiar historical story. The beginning of the modern period supposedly restricted earlier frankness about sex to a narrow set of acceptable settings, culminating in a Victorian order that made respectable married reproduction the rule. In the same story, speaking openly later becomes a way to challenge that order. Foucault takes the attraction of the story seriously. It gives even a simple statement about sex the force of confronting a longstanding prohibition. He asks whether the history of what people could say, and of the institutions that spoke on their behalf, fits it. The History of Sexuality, vol. I, part I, “We ‘Other Victorians’”.
He separates three doubts. One concerns what happened historically from the seventeenth century onward. Did sexual discourse primarily contract? Another concerns the workings of power. Can prohibition and censorship account for how power operated wherever people were asked about sex? The third concerns the people who set out to resist repression. Is the demand to disclose a sexual truth wholly independent of the practices in which that demand became intelligible? These questions can receive different answers. Evidence that an institution prohibited an act is compatible with evidence that it increased attention to that act. Even successfully challenging the prohibition can leave some of the institution's ways of describing people in place. The History of Sexuality, vol. I, part I.
Imagine reading two documents from the same school. One tells pupils what language they may not use in public. The other tells staff what details to record and report to the head teacher. The growth of regulated speech in the second cannot tell us how free the pupils were to speak in the first. A history of discourse has to ask who spoke to whom, what counted as evidence, and what the recipients were in a position to do with it. Foucault calls attention to the way a silence can be arranged together with explicit talk elsewhere. The History of Sexuality, vol. I, part II, ch. 1, “The Incitement to Discourse”.
What a confession can be made to reveal
In the Christian pastoral practices Foucault discusses, confessors came to be concerned with details beyond a prohibited act. A person could be expected to search thoughts, pleasures, intentions, and memories for signs of what was at stake. At the same time, conventions about the language and the place of the account became more careful. The rule of discretion helped determine the form in which the account was given. The requirement to give an account could become more demanding even where opportunities to discuss the subject in other ways were restricted. The History of Sexuality, vol. I, part II, ch. 1.
Foucault traces a set of changes as techniques of confession became linked with medicine, psychiatry, and other inquiries. An investigator can listen for a sign the speaker does not recognize, record it in relation to an earlier history, or reinterpret the speaker's inability to give an answer. These are ways in which the listener helps determine what the account will establish. They also change what a speaker might have to do to make sense of their situation. If the explanation of a present difficulty is supposed to lie in an early experience the person barely remembers, they can be prompted to search and describe their past in much greater detail. Foucault treats this as a production of knowledge, alongside any question one can ask about the truth of a particular report. The History of Sexuality, vol. I, part III, “Scientia Sexualis”.
A person can tell something they know while the authority listening takes the answer as evidence for something different. Suppose someone tells a clinician that they remember a relationship vividly. The detail could be used to understand the importance of the relationship, or treated as a clue to an underlying type of character. In the second case, the organizing question matters to what will enter the record. The difference is visible without assuming that the person has invented the memory or that there is nothing real to discover. It concerns how an exchange makes certain claims about a person possible. The History of Sexuality, vol. I, part III.
Scientific status has to be made credible within such an exchange. Foucault describes how questionnaires and examinations combine a personal history with symptoms the investigator takes to be observable. The result may be arranged to look comparable to other cases. The premise that sex can have effects throughout a life then gives investigators reasons to pursue details that would be irrelevant in a narrower inquiry. A further premise makes it possible to interpret something a person did not say explicitly as evidence of a truth concealed from them. Each premise changes the role of the person answering and of the authority who writes the case. The History of Sexuality, vol. I, part III.
How a case becomes a kind of person
One of Foucault's examples compares an old legal treatment of sodomy with a nineteenth-century medical and psychiatric account of homosexuality. In the contrast he draws, the legal treatment takes a prohibited act as its central object. The medical description treats a type of person as its object, with a developmental history, particular traits, and a sexual disposition through which the person's past and present might be understood. This is an argument about the change in a way of classifying people. It does not establish that same-sex desires began at a particular moment, or that earlier people lacked every way of describing their own attachments. The History of Sexuality, vol. I, part II, ch. 2, “The Perverse Implantation”.
The inquiry into children's masturbation gives another example of how the target of intervention was elaborated. Parents and educators could be told that a habit had to be prevented and that it might go unnoticed. The advice could then direct them to search rooms, change sleeping arrangements, monitor conduct, and consult physicians. Those steps give the practice an importance as an object of observation beyond its importance as something the adults wish to stop. Foucault asks why some forms of scrutiny multiplied in the name of making what they watched disappear. The example shows how a particular prohibition can bring activity, investigation, and records into being. The History of Sexuality, vol. I, part II, ch. 2.
In the chapter called “Domain,” Foucault groups some characteristic strategies. He describes the medicalization of women's bodies in relation to family and child health, the surveillance and instruction surrounding children's sexual activity, the regulation of reproductive behavior, and the psychiatric classification of pleasures considered abnormal. Their objects differ. A family can become a place where several meet. A parent may be asked to report a child's behavior to a doctor while taking medical advice about their own conduct and the health of other household members. The family is part of the organization that gives these matters a place in daily life. The History of Sexuality, vol. I, part IV, ch. 3, “Domain”.
The book contrasts this activity with the older deployment of alliance, the ordering of marriage, kinship, and the transmission of names and property. The two arrangements can work through the same household. A relative may apply one standard when asking whether a marriage is permitted and another when discussing the couple’s health, feelings, or children. Foucault treats the family as a point of passage between the arrangements. Rules of kinship can make particular relationships important, and inquiry about intimacy can give them a meaning those rules did not supply. That overlap explains why he approaches the family as an active setting for the production of sexual discourse. The History of Sexuality, vol. I, part IV, ch. 3.
Two ways of taking charge of life
The last part of the book distinguishes the sovereign right to take life or let live from arrangements that take the management of life as an object. Foucault calls attention to two poles of this power over life. At one pole, disciplines train and use individual bodies, making them more capable and easier to direct. He calls this an anatomo-politics of the body. At the other, a biopolitics of populations attends to birth rates, mortality, longevity, and conditions that alter them. These are complementary parts of the account of biopower. Foucault's historical claim does not entail that rights, courts, and practices of killing disappear once regulation becomes important. The History of Sexuality, vol. I, part V, “Right of Death and Power over Life”.
Biopower concerns both the training and use of individual bodies and the regulation of populations. In this volume, the population pole is the one Foucault specifically calls biopolitics. Sexuality matters to the analysis because an intervention can connect how people use their bodies with decisions about a population's health or reproduction.
Consider an authority that wants to affect births. It can compare rates across groups or follow how they change over time. But changing those rates can involve advice, requirements, or incentives directed at people making choices about their lives. The other direction is possible too. An educational campaign can ask parents to supervise a child differently by claiming that an individual's conduct has consequences for a whole population. Foucault discusses how the pressure of a general aim reaches the time, habits, and circumstances of particular people. The account asks where the individual and population levels are joined, and which of the two supplies the stated reason for intervention in a particular case. The History of Sexuality, vol. I, part V.
The visibility created by population statistics is also different from the visibility in a confession. A person can be counted without having told a long story. A case can be described in detail without supplying much evidence about a population. An institution that combines these techniques can move between a concern about this individual and a concern about trends. Foucault's distinction makes it possible to see what is added each time. Archival records, statistical observations, and statements made during an examination can become reasons to act at different scales.
Foucault adds that the administration of life can coexist with practices that expose people to death. His historical discussion asks how the defense of a population can become a justification for violence, including violence directed against part of that population or against other populations. The claim is that concern for life can be selective and can furnish a new rationale for force. That differs from saying that an increased interest in health inevitably produces violence. It calls for a history of which people came to count as a population to be protected, how threats to that population were defined, and what those definitions made possible. The History of Sexuality, vol. I, part V.
Power, purpose, and resistance
Foucault proposes examining local relations before assuming that every practice comes from one center. A doctor may have an explicit purpose in asking a question. A school can have a detailed procedure for recording a problem. Several such practices can eventually support a wider way of regulating households or classifying a population without anyone having devised every element. The proposal does not give us permission to infer a comprehensive strategy from any repeated form of questioning. It asks how the purposes and effects of specific practices came to be aligned, and where their alignment remained unstable. The History of Sexuality, vol. I, part IV, chs. 1–2.
A classification can also serve a use different from the one for which it was first employed. Foucault observes that persons described in the language of medicine and law could use some of the same terms in asking for recognition of the legitimacy of homosexuality. He calls this a reverse discourse. Using inherited terms restricts how a claim is initially framed, yet the people making it can contest what the terms authorize others to do. More generally, Foucault places resistance within the same relations in which power operates. A clinician, a pupil, or a group seeking recognition can answer a demand in ways that change what someone else has to account for. Such responses can succeed or fail and can matter differently across institutions. The History of Sexuality, vol. I, part IV, ch. 2, “Method”.
One implication of that approach is that the same form of speech can be effective in different directions. An institution can invite someone to speak in order to place them in an existing category. Members of a group can also speak so they are recognized on different terms, or organize to challenge the authority of the people who classified them. Whether the later use keeps the category intact is a further question. Foucault asks after the effects of a particular use, including cases where speech gives different people resources they can wield against each other. The History of Sexuality, vol. I, part IV, ch. 2.
The challenge for the historical account is to make differences among those cases visible. A court record may tell us what conduct a law targeted and reveal a way of describing the accused. It may tell us little about how people privately understood the conduct. A medical account may document a highly structured interview with one doctor. It offers no immediate evidence that all families understand the phenomenon in the same way. If a claim covers several institutions or decades, each extension calls for its own evidence. The first volume sketches a program for those inquiries and gives readers grounds to examine where its claims are strongest.
Foucault's initial question then comes back in a more precise form. What difference does it make to be able to disclose something? Being heard can have effects that a prohibition prevented. The place of disclosure also matters. Who asked for the story, who interprets it, and what can be done once it has become part of a record? The repressive hypothesis leaves that part of the exchange easy to overlook. The volume asks us to consider the particular possibilities a new way of speaking opens and the arrangements it brings with it.
Further reading
- Michel Foucault, The History of Sexuality, volume I, translated by Robert Hurley. Part I sets out the three doubts about the repressive hypothesis. Parts II and III trace the incitement to discourse and confession, part IV develops the method, and part V distinguishes the two poles of biopower.
Join the discussionAsk a question or share what you learned.
Keep exploring
Reference
Citation details
Cite or share this article.

Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!