Benjamin's Theses on the Philosophy of History

Michael BrenndoerferUpdated January 27, 202613 min read

Walter Benjamin's 1940 reflections on progress, historical memory, and the claims of the past on the present.

PhilosophyAll chapters
Reading tools Notes & comments
Notes & comments
Part 11 of 12Power, History, and Social Criticism
Chapter 137Progress and the claims of the past › The Angel Faces the Past
Reading the full chapter · 7 sections · 13 min7 sections · 13 min

All 7 sections · 13 min read

Progress and the claims of the past › The Angel Faces the PastFull chapter · Sections in this chapter1 / 7 ↓

The Angel Faces the Past

There is a small figure with raised wings in Paul Klee's Angelus Novus. Walter Benjamin bought the 1920 oil-transfer drawing in 1921. In thesis IX of “On the Concept of History”, written in 1940, he imagines the figure looking back at the past. Where we see a succession of events, the angel sees wreckage accumulating in a single catastrophe. It wants to stop, awaken the dead, and repair what was broken. A storm catches its wings and carries it into the future with its back turned.

The storm is what people call progress. That association changes the direction from which a familiar story is told. We often assess historical change by looking toward a result and treating earlier losses as stages on the way to it. Benjamin's angel sees those losses without having the power to repair them. The violence is not put in order for it by a destination ahead. The drawing supplies the figure. The wreckage, the storm, and the interpretation of its flight belong to Benjamin's thesis.

Benjamin's eighteen numbered theses and their appendices approach history in different ways. One describes the unacknowledged labor that produces cultural treasures. Another examines what happens when people treat fascism as an anomaly their age should have left behind. Several describe how a particular experience of the past can interrupt the sense that one moment follows another on a predictable course. Read together, they ask what we fail to see about history when the appearance of forward movement settles how we judge it.

Why Progress Can Be a Bad Explanation

In thesis XIII, Benjamin criticizes a view of progress he associates with social democratic theory and practice. It treats progress as the improvement of humanity itself, as unending, and as essentially unstoppable. His objection goes deeper than denying any one of those attributes. They share a conception of time in which progress can be imagined as continuing through a sequence of uniform moments. Benjamin calls it homogeneous, empty time.

Ordinary chronology is indispensable for many historical questions. We need dates to know whether a law was passed before or after a strike and to establish which decisions people could have responded to. Benjamin's target is the story that can be put on that sequence, as if its forward movement by itself told us how humanity is doing. One can register changes in knowledge and productive capacity without assuming they carry everyone toward emancipation. The angel gives the failure of that assumption a visual form.

In thesis VIII, the history of oppressed people supplies a different measure of what counts as ordinary. A condition experienced as an emergency can be recurrent or customary from their point of view. If we treat their experiences as exceptions, we may suppose the main course of history is making such things increasingly impossible. Benjamin asks what happens when the advance of fascism makes that conviction untenable. The surprise that such things are still possible tells us something about the idea of history that made us surprised.

Benjamin uses the language of an emergency twice in that thesis. One use concerns the condition the oppressed know as the rule. The other concerns a real interruption to be brought about in the struggle against fascism. Simply announcing that the ordinary course of things has been suspended would not make the two uses equivalent. We have to ask whose ordinary course is in view and what the interruption is meant to change. The link to action makes this more than a question about whether progress is a good name for the past.

The Work Buried Inside a Cultural Treasure

Thesis VII imagines victors passing on what they have won in a triumphal procession. Cultural treasures are among the things they carry. An achievement may owe its existence to skilled makers and to less visible labor performed under harsh conditions. Its later preservation and transfer can also reproduce relations of power. Benjamin asks a historian to pay attention to both its making and the way it came down to us.

Imagine the authorized history of a public building. It names the architect, describes the opening ceremony, and shows the people who commissioned it. Those details can all be accurate. If the history records the names and designs that entered the public record while leaving the conditions of construction unexamined, it can repeat the standpoint from which the building was celebrated. A different account would use information about who worked on it, what they could refuse, and how the site came to be available. There is no need to stop looking at the architecture to ask about those conditions.

Benjamin calls the task reading history against the grain. It demands attention to the means by which some experiences and achievements become visible and others recede. Someone whose name is missing from the register may have had much to do with the thing the register celebrates. The absence of that person's record can itself become a question about how the register was made. Recognizing a silence does not tell us what to put in its place. It tells us why further historical work is needed.

The angle on cultural inheritance also matters for the historian's sympathies. Benjamin argues that an easy identification with the victors benefits those in power in the present. An account can inherit an allegiance even while it strives to reproduce past events faithfully. One way to examine that allegiance is to ask whose success makes the story cohere, and which losses it asks the reader to accept as the cost of an achievement. The building requires a different description once those questions are allowed to interrupt the story of its completion.

A Memory Becomes Legible in a Moment of Danger

In theses V–VI, Benjamin describes the past through an image that can flash into recognition. The image appears in a present where it matters and may be lost if that present fails to recognize the connection. A moment of danger can threaten both a tradition and the people who inherit it. The risk is that the tradition will be reshaped to serve those who dominate it.

A particular record might be preserved for years and come to matter in a new way when a conflict returns. Imagine minutes describing workers' opposition to a safety practice. A later manager cites the minutes as evidence that employees were consulted. In another moment, workers facing a related danger might see them as evidence of an unresolved objection. The words in the minutes have not changed. Their use and the questions through which they become legible have changed. The example illustrates what can be at stake in retrieving a record rather than merely preserving it.

Benjamin's rejection of the historian's claim to describe the past simply as it really was does not turn the record into evidence for whatever we wish to say. A historical account can be wrong about what happened, who acted, and what was possible then. The question he raises is what gives the surviving trace its significance for a historian in a particular present. A later struggle can help make previously overlooked evidence intelligible. It can also generate temptations to make the past say too much. How a reading treats the actual record remains important for telling those cases apart.

Thesis II gives the relation to the past a name. Benjamin speaks of a weak messianic power held by each generation, on which the past has a claim. Notice the direction of the claim. The present inherits unfinished matters for which it can become answerable. The scope of its power is limited. The historian cannot literally give a different life to the dead, any more than the angel can undo the wreckage as it is driven away. Yet what the present remembers and carries forward can still make a difference to the defeat or appropriation of what earlier people attempted.

Thesis XII puts this in a political register. Benjamin contrasts motivations drawn from the memory of people already subjected to oppression with an assurance that later generations will be free. The example explains why he objects to imagining emancipation as the normal result of a long process. An expectation about the future can be morally powerful. It gives a different reason for acting from a memory of injury and a sense of what the present still owes.

The description of historical materialism in thesis IV complicates the idea that the materialist historian simply records who took control of land, food, or tools. These are real matters at stake in class struggle. Benjamin also names qualities such as courage and humor that can be present in struggle without being possessions captured by whichever side wins. An unsuccessful effort can show what people were able to imagine or do together even though they did not change who held power. A later observer can see that effort without being able to regard it as a victory.

This is one reason to be careful about what a history of failure records. An account organized around the outcome may tell us only that a group's demands were refused. There may be evidence about forms of organization, mutual support, and judgment that developed through making the demands. These can matter again although the group's objective remained out of reach. The distinction helps preserve what people did without telling a compensatory story in which their failure had to happen for someone else's later success.

Thesis III offers a perspective in which events do not have to be treated as inherently too small to remember. Benjamin casts the prospect of a past citable in all its moments in the theological register of redemption and the Last Judgment. A working historian still has to select questions and evidence. The passage makes it possible to ask what authorizes the starting division between events the historian has a reason to consider and events already written off. The apparent smallness of a thing in the received account may tell us more about how the account was assembled than about the thing itself.

What Benjamin Means by Now-Time

The German text of theses XIV–XVII uses Jetztzeit, often rendered as now-time. In thesis XIV, Benjamin's example is the French Revolution's recollection of ancient Rome. An aspect of the past becomes charged with significance for a later present. The effect is more like a citation in an argument than a simple continuation of a sequence. Bringing ancient Rome into revolutionary language does not make the intervening centuries disappear. It changes which historical relationship is important at that moment.

Thesis XV turns to calendars and clocks. The example of a revolutionary calendar concerns the act of marking a beginning and recalling it again on particular days. A clock gives units that can be counted in the same way across days. A commemorative day can express a historical difference between one moment and another that the clock was never meant to register. Benjamin also recounts shots directed at clock faces during the July Revolution. He treats the episode as an image of a revolutionary awareness of time, rather than as a demonstration that people can literally stop time.

In thesis XVII, Benjamin contrasts an approach that adds facts to a universal chronicle with a constructive one. An object can bring several relationships into view at once. A work can illuminate a life, the life a historical period, and the period a wider course of events. Benjamin uses the term monad to suggest this concentration. The claim is not that an individual object yields every fact about its period. It can let conflicts of the period become briefly readable together.

Consider the public building again. A detail in its records might connect the way it was funded, the labor on the site, and the political decision to commemorate it. The historian can follow those relations when deciding what period or set of practices the detail illuminates. A catalogue organized by date would still have its uses. The construction Benjamin is describing asks what becomes visible when the detail is allowed to reorganize the questions rather than being given a small place in a story already decided.

Remembrance and the Future

In appendix B, Benjamin turns to remembrance and the Jewish prohibition on trying to divine the future. The appendix gives each instant the possibility of opening to a messianic arrival. It does not place that arrival on a timetable or provide a formula by which historical laws could predict it. This is a pointed return to the argument about time. A future represented as a sequence of empty units waiting to be filled leaves no special force to the opening of any particular moment.

The theological phrases in the theses are difficult to treat as ornamental. The first thesis pictures a chess-playing automaton operated from inside by a concealed player. Historical materialism is likened to the visible mechanism and theology to the partner it keeps out of sight. The image brings the two into an unstable arrangement. It is not a systematic account of how revelation or divine action enters politics. It tells the reader to attend to what the historical account may be borrowing from ideas of judgment and redemption.

One question this leaves is how a political decision can be both limited and significant. Remembering a defeat does not guarantee that a present response will be effective. Benjamin still gives the present responsibility for what can be carried forward and what may disappear. The image of the opening in appendix B makes this possibility harder to identify with a forecast. It asks what can become available in a moment when an older experience is recognized.

Appendix A helps relate that possibility to questions of historical causation. A person can establish that one event helped bring about another and still miss the significance an earlier event takes on for a later period. Benjamin calls the meeting of the two periods a constellation. This does not require treating our present as the point toward which the old events were already headed. The relationship may depend on what we can now see, including questions the people who acted then could not have put in the same way.

The importance of the theses on time can be tested against that distinction. A cause can be recorded in a chronological account. A historical judgment also draws together what a present conflict makes visible and what has survived from an earlier one. Those surviving things put limits on what can be said now. The same act of recognition can also make familiar explanations open to challenge.

Reading the Theses

The Dennis Redmond translation gives the numbered theses and appendices together. Start with II on the claim of the past, VI–VIII on tradition and danger, IX on the angel, and XIII–XVII on time and historical construction. Then read appendix B separately from thesis XVIII. The German text makes it possible to compare the language of Jetztzeit and of bringing thought or historical movement to a standstill. Translator choices vary, so the numbering is the surest way to locate a passage.

Join the discussionAsk a question or share what you learned.

Comments

Add to the conversation

A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!

A different angle
All writing
Philosophy

Arendt's The Origins of Totalitarianism: Understanding Political Evil

Hannah Arendt's 1951 essential work for understanding twentieth-century political catastrophe as a novel form of evil, analyzing antisemitism, imperialism, and totalitarian movements.

13 min read
Philosophy

Arendt's The Human Condition: Labor, Work, and Action

Hannah Arendt's 1958 original analysis of labor, work, and action that distinguishes genuine political action from mere behavior and recovers the vita activa.

13 min read
Philosophy

Beauvoir's The Second Sex: Woman as Other

Simone de Beauvoir's 1949 foundational feminist philosophy applying existentialist categories to analyze woman as 'Other' and the construction of femininity.

13 min read

About the author

Reference

Citation details

Cite or share this article.

BIBTEXAcademic
@misc{brenndoerfer2026benjamins, author = {Michael Brenndoerfer}, title = {Benjamin's Theses on the Philosophy of History}, year = {2026}, url = {https://mbrenndoerfer.com/writing/benjamin-theses-philosophy-history-angel-guide}, organization = {mbrenndoerfer.com}, note = {Accessed: 2026-11-19} }
APAAcademic
Michael Brenndoerfer (2026). Benjamin's Theses on the Philosophy of History. Retrieved from https://mbrenndoerfer.com/writing/benjamin-theses-philosophy-history-angel-guide
MLAAcademic
Michael Brenndoerfer. "Benjamin's Theses on the Philosophy of History." 2026. Web. November 19, 2026. <https://mbrenndoerfer.com/writing/benjamin-theses-philosophy-history-angel-guide>.
CHICAGOAcademic
Michael Brenndoerfer. "Benjamin's Theses on the Philosophy of History." Accessed November 19, 2026. https://mbrenndoerfer.com/writing/benjamin-theses-philosophy-history-angel-guide.
HARVARDAcademic
Michael Brenndoerfer (2026) 'Benjamin's Theses on the Philosophy of History'. Available at: https://mbrenndoerfer.com/writing/benjamin-theses-philosophy-history-angel-guide (Accessed: November 19, 2026).
SimpleBasic
Michael Brenndoerfer (2026). Benjamin's Theses on the Philosophy of History. https://mbrenndoerfer.com/writing/benjamin-theses-philosophy-history-angel-guide
Newsletter

Stay up to date

Get new articles, book updates, and notes on AI and technology.

Unsubscribe at any time. Privacy policy