Progress and the claims of the past › What Benjamin Means by Now-Time
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Progress and the claims of the past › What Benjamin Means by Now-TimeSection view · Sections in this chapter5 / 7 ↓
The German text of theses XIV–XVII uses Jetztzeit, often rendered as now-time. In thesis XIV, Benjamin's example is the French Revolution's recollection of ancient Rome. An aspect of the past becomes charged with significance for a later present. The effect is more like a citation in an argument than a simple continuation of a sequence. Bringing ancient Rome into revolutionary language does not make the intervening centuries disappear. It changes which historical relationship is important at that moment.
Thesis XV turns to calendars and clocks. The example of a revolutionary calendar concerns the act of marking a beginning and recalling it again on particular days. A clock gives units that can be counted in the same way across days. A commemorative day can express a historical difference between one moment and another that the clock was never meant to register. Benjamin also recounts shots directed at clock faces during the July Revolution. He treats the episode as an image of a revolutionary awareness of time, rather than as a demonstration that people can literally stop time.
In thesis XVII, Benjamin contrasts an approach that adds facts to a universal chronicle with a constructive one. An object can bring several relationships into view at once. A work can illuminate a life, the life a historical period, and the period a wider course of events. Benjamin uses the term monad to suggest this concentration. The claim is not that an individual object yields every fact about its period. It can let conflicts of the period become briefly readable together.
Consider the public building again. A detail in its records might connect the way it was funded, the labor on the site, and the political decision to commemorate it. The historian can follow those relations when deciding what period or set of practices the detail illuminates. A catalogue organized by date would still have its uses. The construction Benjamin is describing asks what becomes visible when the detail is allowed to reorganize the questions rather than being given a small place in a story already decided.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!