Progress and the claims of the past › Remembrance and the Future
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Progress and the claims of the past › Remembrance and the FutureSection view · Sections in this chapter6 / 7 ↓
In appendix B, Benjamin turns to remembrance and the Jewish prohibition on trying to divine the future. The appendix gives each instant the possibility of opening to a messianic arrival. It does not place that arrival on a timetable or provide a formula by which historical laws could predict it. This is a pointed return to the argument about time. A future represented as a sequence of empty units waiting to be filled leaves no special force to the opening of any particular moment.
The theological phrases in the theses are difficult to treat as ornamental. The first thesis pictures a chess-playing automaton operated from inside by a concealed player. Historical materialism is likened to the visible mechanism and theology to the partner it keeps out of sight. The image brings the two into an unstable arrangement. It is not a systematic account of how revelation or divine action enters politics. It tells the reader to attend to what the historical account may be borrowing from ideas of judgment and redemption.
One question this leaves is how a political decision can be both limited and significant. Remembering a defeat does not guarantee that a present response will be effective. Benjamin still gives the present responsibility for what can be carried forward and what may disappear. The image of the opening in appendix B makes this possibility harder to identify with a forecast. It asks what can become available in a moment when an older experience is recognized.
Appendix A helps relate that possibility to questions of historical causation. A person can establish that one event helped bring about another and still miss the significance an earlier event takes on for a later period. Benjamin calls the meeting of the two periods a constellation. This does not require treating our present as the point toward which the old events were already headed. The relationship may depend on what we can now see, including questions the people who acted then could not have put in the same way.
The importance of the theses on time can be tested against that distinction. A cause can be recorded in a chronological account. A historical judgment also draws together what a present conflict makes visible and what has survived from an earlier one. Those surviving things put limits on what can be said now. The same act of recognition can also make familiar explanations open to challenge.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!