Marx and Engels’s Communist Manifesto: Class and Political Action
Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels’s 1848 pamphlet traces the rise of wage labor, the organization of workers, and the struggle over who controls production.
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Class and political conflict › Who Has the Power to Change the Workshop?Full chapter · Sections in this chapter1 / 7 ↓
Who Has the Power to Change the Workshop?
Suppose a factory installs a machine that allows half as many workers to fill the same orders. Its owner may look at the saving and see the room needed to compete with other factories. One worker may see a chance to learn a new trade. Another may wonder whether there will still be a shift on Monday. Each has reason to care about the same change. What they can do about it depends on their position in the arrangement that makes production possible.
Marx and Engels write about the way such positions arise, how they shape a dispute, and how the people who occupy them might change the arrangement itself. The argument starts with ownership and work, then moves to the political possibilities of groups whose interests are affected by both. The factory example is ours. The nineteenth-century development described in section I of the Manifesto involves newer machines, longer chains of trade, and the erosion of older trades through competition. Those changes carry different consequences for the owners of capital and the people seeking wages.
That distinction allows us to read two kinds of sentence in this short book. There are explanations of what is going on in a society, and there are calls for people to act in it. The movement from the first to the second is a large part of the argument. It is worth pausing at the points where a tendency described in a workshop or a market becomes a claim about political power. Even if we grant the explanation, we can still ask what would make the proposed action possible and what would follow from it.
The Communist League commissioned the text late in 1847, and the German manuscript went to the printer in London early in 1848. In his preface to the 1888 English edition, Engels describes it as a program for the League. A program can make a strong claim about history in order to persuade its readers to organize. Its argument has to support that claim on the page.
How the Two Classes Come Into View
The opening of section I presents class struggle as an organizing feature of recorded history. Marx and Engels name different relations across different societies. A person held in slavery stands in a different relation to a slaveholder from the one in which a journeyman stands to a guild master. The comparison asks us to examine who can direct work and appropriate its results under the institutions of each society. It also leaves room for sharply different outcomes. The text describes both a transformation of society and the ruin of the groups caught in a struggle. Engels's later annotation qualifies the opening formulation by referring to written history. Manifesto, section I and the notes to the 1888 English edition
The bourgeoisie in this argument is the class that owns the means of social production and employs wage labor. The proletariat is the class that has to earn a living by selling its capacity to work. That last point locates the relation quite precisely. A well-paid worker can still depend on continuing to find employment. A shopkeeper who owns tools and sells a product may have very little income while retaining some direct control over production. Income alone will not tell us where either of them stands. Engels gives these definitions in a note to the 1888 English edition. The argument of the 1848 text develops the distinction through the way industry organizes employment. Manifesto, section I and note on the two classes
The text presents those two groups as increasingly opposed. A tendency toward that opposition can operate in a society with other groups. The same section discusses small tradespeople, independent artisans and peasants. Some can lose their position when large producers can buy machinery or reach markets they cannot. To imagine a small workshop finding it harder to compete is to imagine a possible change in a person's relation to production. We would still need to look at the workshop's costs and its customers to say whether that change will occur in a given case.
Marx and Engels treat the bourgeoisie as an agent of substantial historical change. They connect its growth with sea routes, colonial trade and access to new markets, then trace a shift from production organized under guilds to manufacture and larger-scale industry. This is their account of the change, with very broad claims packed into a few pages. For the argument at hand, it asks us to see capitalist production as an arrangement that continues to transform the circumstances in which it operates. To remain in business under pressure from competitors, an owner can have reasons to alter the tools, the division of tasks and the people on whom the enterprise relies. These decisions can change which skills remain saleable and where people need to live in order to find work. Manifesto, section I
When a Dispute About Wages Becomes Political
Consider a group of workers who have the same complaint about their pay. If each takes the complaint to a supervisor separately, the owner can respond to each under different terms. If the workers agree to make a common demand and stick to it, the owner has a different bargaining problem. It may then cost more to replace the group or suspend production than to consider the demand. Whether that is so depends on the group's ability to act together and on the alternatives the owner has. Shared circumstances give the workers something to organize around. The organization does additional work.
Marx and Engels describe several stages that help us understand this step. Resistance can begin with people at one workplace or in one trade. Concentration puts more people in a position to recognize a common concern. Trade and transport connect places that might have remained separate. The text even points to communications produced by industry as a way for workers to connect local disputes. It also recognizes that workers compete among themselves. Their ability to divide the work of organizing, risk a loss of wages and endure a setback will vary. The account includes forces that make association possible as well as ones that can disrupt it. Manifesto, section I, the passage on workers' associations
A political struggle has a larger object than the pay in one workshop. For example, if a restriction on hours is made law, a firm that cuts hours no longer needs to act in isolation while its competitors keep the old schedule. Marx and Engels cite English legislation limiting the working day as an instance in which worker organization obtains legal recognition. Their example also involves divisions among the people who control capital. Competing interests among owners can matter to what a workers' movement can achieve. A reading that pictures two perfectly unified groups misses this part of the explanation.
From there, the authors make the much stronger claim that bourgeois rule and the conditions that reproduce it will eventually be overturned. They see a class that industry brings into existence as capable of changing the relations on which that industry depends. As readers we can grant that workers in different places can learn to act together and ask what would make the organization last through a political defeat. We can also ask whether success at winning legal protections might strengthen class organization or give workers reason to pursue their aims within the existing institutions. These questions test the connection between the proposed mechanism and the predicted result.
Two people can occupy the same position in an enterprise while preferring different ways to respond to a threat. Given a common risk, their ability to act jointly depends on what support they can obtain and how secure they are against retaliation. Look for places in section I where Marx and Engels describe that intervening work of organization.
What the Authors Mean by Abolishing Bourgeois Property
A family that uses a stove and an owner who uses a factory both possess things. Both might have legally protected claims. Yet property in a factory can give the owner the authority to employ people and exercise control over their work. Section II singles out the historically specific form of property that enables a class to exercise this power. In replying to the charge that they want to end all appropriation, Marx and Engels say the objection concerns the social means by which some gain power over the labor of others. People can still take and use what they need to live in the society the authors envision. Manifesto, section II
The distinction also helps explain why an individual owner's intentions carry limited weight in the analysis. Imagine that one business owner takes pains to treat employees well. If the business still depends on the owner's authority to decide how the equipment will be used and on the employees' need to sell their capacity to work, the relationship analyzed by the text persists. The normative question is what powers people should have over productive resources and over the terms under which others use them. That can be asked even when the particular people involved have done nothing wrong by the ordinary rules of the enterprise.
Marx and Engels give their program an immediate political aim. They call for the proletariat to constitute itself as a political class and win political power. The transitional measures near the end of section II address matters such as land, taxation, credit and education. The text says that the measures will vary from country to country. Its 1872 German preface, written after the Paris Commune, explains that the program's specific steps would be framed differently in light of subsequent experience. In particular, the authors qualify what it would mean for the working class to use existing state machinery. The distinction between the end of the transformation and the measures adopted along the way is present from the start and becomes explicit when they revisit the book. Manifesto, section II and 1872 preface
The section's account of the projected end gives the free development of individuals a central place. Its claim is that the development of each is to be a condition for the development of all. A difficulty for the program is to explain how collective authority over production would secure that development. Suppose a group gains the power to set the terms of access to the workshop. Who can challenge its decisions, and how might people who need the workshop get a hearing? The text gives an aim by which to judge the transformation. It leaves considerable work to anyone trying to work out an institutional form that meets that aim.
Why the Later Sections Debate Other Programs
The authors devote section III to kinds of socialist and communist writing they criticize. The distinctions matter because writers can agree that industrial conditions are severe and disagree about what to do about them. The Manifesto treats the wish to restore older social arrangements differently from a program that proposes remedies within bourgeois society. It also credits earlier socialist critics with making aspects of the existing society visible while objecting to strategies that expect exemplary communities or appeals to society at large to deliver a transformation. Those polemical descriptions are the authors' assessment of their rivals. We can use the distinctions to ask what an argument for change expects to move the people who could carry it out. Manifesto, section III
Section IV discusses cooperation with other opposition movements. In the discussion of Germany, for instance, it allows cooperation with the bourgeoisie against absolute monarchy and other forces of the old order while insisting that workers understand their eventual conflict with the bourgeoisie itself. One reason to read this section after the account of class is that it shows how agreement over a particular political goal can coexist with disagreement about what should come next. Allies can share an interest in removing a barrier while having very different plans for the institutions that replace it. Political organization has to account for both facts. Manifesto, section IV
There is a similar distinction in the discussion of ideas in section II. Marx and Engels link changes in prevailing ideas to changes in material and social relations. An interpretation of that claim should specify the connection it proposes. Consider a dispute about who gets to direct an enterprise. A legal vocabulary of ownership can make one party's authority seem like an ordinary consequence of property. The same parties might defend their positions differently once the rules allow workers to participate in decisions. Recognizing a connection between rules and the ways people justify authority still leaves us free to examine individual arguments and to say why some succeed or fail.
What to Look For on a Second Reading
Return to the new machine. Before drawing a conclusion, ask who can decide to install it and how the possible gains or losses will be distributed. Then ask whether workers can make common demands and whether they can change the rules that determine their share. Those are distinct questions even when the answer to one changes how the others should be asked. An owner can control the machinery and still face constraints imposed by creditors, suppliers, customers or law. Workers may have a reason to agree about the threat and find it difficult to agree on which demand to make. If a political response succeeds, we can ask how its success changes the possibilities for further action.
A further question belongs to the example. Suppose the agreement preserves every shift by letting the firm buy fewer machines. The workers have won something, and the firm may still be vulnerable to a competitor with lower costs. A settlement at one factory leaves decisions at its competitors outside the bargain. A legal rule changes the scope of the decision by binding comparable firms. If we want to know which remedy could last, we need to identify which parties can avoid it and how easily.
The Manifesto makes the structure of this example visible. It asks us to understand which interests are created by a relationship, then to look at the means by which people come together and act on those interests. That first description can be tested without assuming that a given revolution will result. As the text shifts from the account of industry to the claim about its future, look for the premises about organization and political power. A reader can dispute those premises in detail while preserving the questions about how people depend on one another in production.
Further Reading
- Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels, Manifesto of the Communist Party. Read sections I and II for the account of industry and property, then compare the shorter sections on rival programs and political alliances.
- Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels, prefaces to later editions of the Manifesto. Compare the 1872 comments on the program with Engels's account of the book's commission and publication in the 1888 preface.
- Karl Marx, Capital, Volume I, chapter 6. The later book gives a more detailed analysis of the purchase and sale of labor-power than the Manifesto attempts.
Join the discussionAsk a question or share what you learned.
Keep exploring
Reference
Citation details
Cite or share this article.

Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!