Class and political conflict › When a Dispute About Wages Becomes Political
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Class and political conflict › When a Dispute About Wages Becomes PoliticalSection view · Sections in this chapter3 / 7 ↓
Consider a group of workers who have the same complaint about their pay. If each takes the complaint to a supervisor separately, the owner can respond to each under different terms. If the workers agree to make a common demand and stick to it, the owner has a different bargaining problem. It may then cost more to replace the group or suspend production than to consider the demand. Whether that is so depends on the group's ability to act together and on the alternatives the owner has. Shared circumstances give the workers something to organize around. The organization does additional work.
Marx and Engels describe several stages that help us understand this step. Resistance can begin with people at one workplace or in one trade. Concentration puts more people in a position to recognize a common concern. Trade and transport connect places that might have remained separate. The text even points to communications produced by industry as a way for workers to connect local disputes. It also recognizes that workers compete among themselves. Their ability to divide the work of organizing, risk a loss of wages and endure a setback will vary. The account includes forces that make association possible as well as ones that can disrupt it. Manifesto, section I, the passage on workers' associations
A political struggle has a larger object than the pay in one workshop. For example, if a restriction on hours is made law, a firm that cuts hours no longer needs to act in isolation while its competitors keep the old schedule. Marx and Engels cite English legislation limiting the working day as an instance in which worker organization obtains legal recognition. Their example also involves divisions among the people who control capital. Competing interests among owners can matter to what a workers' movement can achieve. A reading that pictures two perfectly unified groups misses this part of the explanation.
From there, the authors make the much stronger claim that bourgeois rule and the conditions that reproduce it will eventually be overturned. They see a class that industry brings into existence as capable of changing the relations on which that industry depends. As readers we can grant that workers in different places can learn to act together and ask what would make the organization last through a political defeat. We can also ask whether success at winning legal protections might strengthen class organization or give workers reason to pursue their aims within the existing institutions. These questions test the connection between the proposed mechanism and the predicted result.
Two people can occupy the same position in an enterprise while preferring different ways to respond to a threat. Given a common risk, their ability to act jointly depends on what support they can obtain and how secure they are against retaliation. Look for places in section I where Marx and Engels describe that intervening work of organization.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!