Marx's Capital: Critique of Political Economy
Karl Marx's 1867 systematic critique of capitalist production, analyzing commodities, labor, surplus value, and the dynamics of capitalist accumulation.
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Commodities, labor, and accumulation › How Does the Money Come Back as More Money?Full chapter · Sections in this chapter1 / 8 ↓
How Does the Money Come Back as More Money?
A spinner agrees to work for a day. Their employer buys cotton, uses a spindle and pays the agreed amount for the day's labor-power. Once the yarn is made, the employer sells it for more than the total laid out on the cotton, the part of the spindle used up, and the worker's capacity to work. Marx asks how this result could follow even if everyone in the example paid the full value of what they bought.
The puzzle sets a condition that will matter throughout the example. If a person gains by selling a commodity for more than its value, the buyer gives up the difference. That transaction may explain the gain made by one party. It leaves open where an addition to the total value comes from. Marx asks us to imagine exchange at value so that we can follow the money through production and isolate a possible source of the addition. His conditions are part of an argument about the origin of surplus. An actual shop's accounts can include changes in prices and costs that the example deliberately sets aside. Capital, volume I, chapter 7
The first volume of Capital begins several chapters earlier with a single commodity. The choice of starting point can seem odd. There is as yet little about the bargaining over work or the use of the finished yarn. But once value is kept apart from usefulness and its expression in exchange, Marx has the vocabulary he needs to say what the employer has bought and what the spinner actually does. The argument is cumulative. Confusing those steps makes it easy to mistake a dispute about the sale price for a dispute about what happened during production.
What a Commodity Has to Do
A coat keeps a person warm. In Marx's terminology, the capacity to meet a want makes it a use-value. A coat produced for sale also enters a relation to other commodities. In the example developed in chapter 1, a particular quantity of linen is expressed as worth one coat. The physical qualities of linen give a person reasons for using it. They do not tell the person why a given length of linen should exchange on those terms. Marx asks which common property allows very different commodities to be compared in the first place. Capital, volume I, chapter 1, §§1–3
Marx approaches the question through labor. The concrete labor of making the coat differs from the concrete labor of weaving the linen. These activities have different steps and create different useful articles. In the comparison of commodities as values, he treats them as socially comparable expenditures of human labor. The relevant quantity for the magnitude of value is the working time socially necessary to produce an article under normal conditions with prevailing skill and intensity. A lone tailor who takes longer than usual has worked for longer. On Marx's account, the coat does not thereby command a larger share of society's labor in exchange.
Think of two workrooms that use the same materials and make coats of the same quality. A cutter in the first takes six hours to do what the second does in four. If four hours reflects the conditions under which comparable coats are normally made, the extra private time in the first room is not an independent reason to count its coat as more valuable. Suppose the first room used the extra time to make a more durable garment. We would then have to reconsider whether the two producers make the same article. The example assumes the products are comparable so that it can bring the distinction between private time and socially necessary time into view.
Marx treats exchange-value as the form in which value appears. Expressing the linen's value in a coat gives it an expression in a different material form. The coat serves as the equivalent in that expression. If we reverse the equation, the relation we have chosen to express also reverses. Marx is interested in that difference because it shows what particular work a commodity is doing in the expression of value. The coat's usefulness remains available to its wearer whichever side of the comparison it occupies.
What Is Bought When Someone Is Hired?
In chapter 6, Marx calls the worker's capacity to labor labor-power. The purchase puts its use at the employer's disposal for an agreed period. The activity of spinning takes place when the employer puts that capacity to work. This produces two quantities to keep track of. There is the value of the daily means required to reproduce labor-power. There is also the value added by the labor performed during the hours for which the capacity is used. The two quantities depend on different circumstances and can diverge. Capital, volume I, chapter 6
Marx gives the wage relation two conditions. A person must be able to dispose of their labor-power and sell its use for a limited period. They must also lack the means to produce commodities of their own at the scale needed to support themselves in the relevant circumstances. In these conditions a person can bargain as the legal owner of their capacity while needing to find a buyer. That combination gives meaning to Marx's treatment of formal equality in exchange and the different powers the parties exercise once the work begins.
The reproduction cost in the argument also has a historical element. The means of subsistence that count as necessary depend in part on what has become customary for workers in particular circumstances. Marx discusses the maintenance of workers, the training necessary for some kinds of work, and the replacement of the workers over generations. We can distinguish this account of labor-power's value from the price paid by a particular employer in a particular labor market. Marx initially assumes payment at value so the distinction between a day's value of the capacity and the activity undertaken during the day remains visible.
Keeping Track of the Spinner's Day
Marx works through quantities in the spinning example in chapter 7. In the longer of two cases, the cotton and used-up portion of the spindle contribute 24 shillings to the finished yarn. A day's labor-power was bought for 3 shillings. The spinner's labor adds 6 shillings. The total laid out for that batch is 27 shillings, and the total value of the yarn is 30 shillings. When the finished yarn sells at that value, the difference is 3 shillings. The example includes the input values already present in the cotton and spindle. The new value is the 6 shillings added by the spinner, of which 3 replace the amount advanced for labor-power. Capital, volume I, chapter 7, §2
We can show the distinction with a separate example expressed in labor-hours. Assume that each hour adds the same amount of new value in both an eight-hour shift and a ten-hour shift. If four hours replace the value of the day's labor-power, four hours of surplus labor remain. The rate of surplus value in that example is the surplus divided by the amount replacing the value of labor-power. Four divided by four is one, or 100 percent. If the shift increases to ten hours and the replacement time remains four hours, six hours are surplus. Six divided by four is 150 percent. The change in the rate in this example comes entirely from two additional hours worked under the stipulated conditions.
In the eight-hour example, surplus labor takes up half the shift. The rate of surplus value is 100 percent because Marx compares surplus with necessary labor, which takes up the other half. A profit rate calculated on total capital advanced would use a different denominator.
In chapter 9, Marx calls the value laid out on the means of production constant capital. He calls the part laid out on labor-power variable capital. In his accounting, cotton passes its existing value into the yarn, and the spindle transfers the value corresponding to the portion used up. The spinner adds new value. To find the rate of surplus value, look at the relation between the resulting surplus and the amount laid out on labor-power. This ratio answers a question about the division of new value. It differs from the share of sales revenue left after recording all the costs of a business. Capital, volume I, chapter 9, §1
Consider also a change in productivity with the length of the shift held fixed. Suppose it makes the means of workers' subsistence cheaper in value terms. If labor-power is still bought at its value, the portion of the shift needed to reproduce that value may fall. At an unchanged rate at which living labor adds new value, the remainder of the same shift then represents a larger surplus. The condition on the means of subsistence matters. A faster way to make an article outside the relevant bundle of goods would not by itself establish that effect. This is one reason to track which process has changed when examining a proposed rise in the rate.
The example's arithmetic can be correct while its premises remain contested. A reader can ask what establishes the proposed connection between social working time and value. Another question concerns the relationship between an analysis of the production of surplus and the price at which a particular capital can sell its output. Neither matter is decided by subtracting 27 shillings from 30. By following the separate entries in the example, we can see which claim we would need to challenge or defend in order to address a specific objection.
Why the Length of the Day Becomes a Dispute
An employer can seek more hours of use from a day's purchase. Workers can have reasons to conserve the capacity they expect to exercise again and to preserve time for the rest of their lives. In chapter 10, Marx presents opposed claims that can both be formulated in the language of commodity exchange. The buyer claims the use of what was bought. The sellers claim the conditions needed to continue supplying their capacity. The exchange itself supplies no clear numerical answer to the question of the normal working day. Marx turns to the conflict over legal limits and the English Factory Acts as part of the answer. Capital, volume I, chapter 10, §§1 and 6
A single business deciding to shorten its shifts may face competitors who retain longer shifts. An industry-wide rule can change that setting by binding comparable firms. The details matter, including which firms are covered, what counts as work, and who can verify that a shift ended. Imagine a factory obeying a maximum in its posted schedule while adopting a separate requirement to clean equipment after the shift. We would need to know whether that activity falls inside the rule's definition of working time. The example shows why a legally specified limit and its enforcement matter together.
If the capitalist redeploys part of the realized surplus to buy additional inputs and labor-power, production can begin again on an expanded scale. Chapter 24 analyzes the conversion of surplus value into additional capital. Marx distinguishes it from the question of how productive resources and people available for hire came to confront one another in the first place. Chapter 26 introduces the latter problem under the name primitive accumulation and describes separation of producers from their means of production. The mechanism that reproduces a relation once established and the events that brought it into existence require different explanations. Capital, volume I, chapter 24 and chapter 26
What Relations Between Things Can Tell Us
If tailors and weavers produce independently for exchange, they find out through exchanges whether others will take their products on the proposed terms. Their labor is interdependent in a practical sense. The weaver needs articles produced by other people and must exchange some of the cloth to obtain them. The amounts of cloth and coats brought to the market affect the possibilities open to both producers. Each encounters part of a social relationship among producers in the form of relations among their products. That way of encountering the relationship is what Marx asks us to attend to in the section on commodity fetishism. Capital, volume I, chapter 1, §4
A person can know every step in making a coat and still have to wait to see whether the finished coat will exchange as expected. Even producers with detailed knowledge about others' work deal with circumstances that come back to them through relations between products. Thus the analysis concerns the organization of production and exchange. It reaches beyond a person's failure to imagine the work behind the goods on a shop shelf. For Marx it matters that the relations acquire an objective form that participants have to reckon with, whatever they privately believe about the objects.
This returns us to the spinner's employer. The person can keep careful accounts of purchases and sales. If the problem is the expansion of value in the example, the figures need to be interpreted in relation to a division of the working day and to whoever has the authority to direct the labor. If the problem is how the growth of an enterprise becomes sustainable, the next entries will concern what the owner can buy with the surplus and under what conditions. Each question gives familiar entries in the accounts a different role.
Reading the Argument in Order
Try using two columns as you read chapters 6 and 7. In the first, record the value advanced for the batch, including cotton, spindle wear, and the day’s labor-power. In the second, record the value transferred by the means of production and the new value added during the day. Then ask which entry, if any, records an explanation of how production can continue at a larger scale. You will need an additional step involving the disposition of the surplus and the next purchases. This is an analytical guide to the order of the argument. It does not ask a reader to infer a full account of a real industry from the quantities Marx supposes.
A second reading can begin with a premise about which you are unsure. You might grant the distinction between the price of a person's labor-power and the use of it during the day while disputing Marx's account of socially necessary labor. Or you might grant his treatment of those quantities and ask why the institutional arrangements of hiring give the employer any claim to the result beyond what was advanced. The close study of exchange and production helps locate the disagreement well enough for that argument to begin.
Further Reading
- Karl Marx, Capital, volume I, chapter 1. Follow linen and the coat through the value expression before reading the closing section on fetishism.
- Karl Marx, Capital, volume I, chapter 7. Compare the first spinning example with the longer working day and account for the change in inputs and yarn.
- Karl Marx, Capital, volume I, chapter 26. Read the chapter's opening explanation of why the origins of the wage relation require a historical account.
Join the discussionAsk a question or share what you learned.
Keep exploring
Reference
Citation details
Cite or share this article.

Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!