Commodities, labor, and accumulation › What a Commodity Has to Do
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Commodities, labor, and accumulation › What a Commodity Has to DoSection view · Sections in this chapter2 / 8 ↓
A coat keeps a person warm. In Marx's terminology, the capacity to meet a want makes it a use-value. A coat produced for sale also enters a relation to other commodities. In the example developed in chapter 1, a particular quantity of linen is expressed as worth one coat. The physical qualities of linen give a person reasons for using it. They do not tell the person why a given length of linen should exchange on those terms. Marx asks which common property allows very different commodities to be compared in the first place. Capital, volume I, chapter 1, §§1–3
Marx approaches the question through labor. The concrete labor of making the coat differs from the concrete labor of weaving the linen. These activities have different steps and create different useful articles. In the comparison of commodities as values, he treats them as socially comparable expenditures of human labor. The relevant quantity for the magnitude of value is the working time socially necessary to produce an article under normal conditions with prevailing skill and intensity. A lone tailor who takes longer than usual has worked for longer. On Marx's account, the coat does not thereby command a larger share of society's labor in exchange.
Think of two workrooms that use the same materials and make coats of the same quality. A cutter in the first takes six hours to do what the second does in four. If four hours reflects the conditions under which comparable coats are normally made, the extra private time in the first room is not an independent reason to count its coat as more valuable. Suppose the first room used the extra time to make a more durable garment. We would then have to reconsider whether the two producers make the same article. The example assumes the products are comparable so that it can bring the distinction between private time and socially necessary time into view.
Marx treats exchange-value as the form in which value appears. Expressing the linen's value in a coat gives it an expression in a different material form. The coat serves as the equivalent in that expression. If we reverse the equation, the relation we have chosen to express also reverses. Marx is interested in that difference because it shows what particular work a commodity is doing in the expression of value. The coat's usefulness remains available to its wearer whichever side of the comparison it occupies.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!