Arendt's The Human Condition: Labor, Work, and Action
Hannah Arendt's 1958 original analysis of labor, work, and action that distinguishes genuine political action from mere behavior and recovers the vita activa.
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Labor, work, and action › Three Things People Do in the Same RoomFull chapter · Sections in this chapter1 / 8 ↓
Three Things People Do in the Same Room
Suppose a neighborhood turns an empty shop into a meeting place. People bring food, wash dishes, and clean the floor so the room can open again the next day. Somebody makes a long table people can use for years. One evening people gather around that table to decide whether to share the room with another group. A proposal that seemed routine changes when the people who would use the room turn up with plans of their own. To understand the place, we need to understand all three kinds of activity.
Hannah Arendt's The Human Condition distinguishes them as labor, work and action. In ordinary speech, we can call everything done in the shop work. In the book, the words name different relationships to time, to made things and to other people. Labor renews the conditions of bodily life. Work makes an artificial world sufficiently durable to outlast many of the activities that use it. Action takes place among people who can speak, initiate something and respond. The distinctions belong to Arendt's account of the vita activa, or active life. The Human Condition, §1
The distinctions describe activities people can move among. A particular person can prepare the meal, repair the table, and argue over who gets to use the room. We can also look at a single episode from more than one angle. Building the room supplies the material conditions for an assembly. Decisions about access can establish relationships that matter long after everyone has gone home. The questions Arendt asks about the activities help us see why having a building and a schedule does not guarantee anybody will be able to take an initiative in them.
Labor and the Needs That Return
A meal is prepared to be eaten. Once people have eaten it, the labor of preparing food will soon be necessary again. This pattern gives Arendt a way to describe the time of labor. Its products enter a living process that consumes them. The process continues while there is life to sustain. Even when a person becomes highly proficient at it, the activity has a relation to need that one well-executed task cannot discharge once and for all. Arendt relates labor to biological life and its renewal. The Human Condition, §§11–14
Think of the people who keep the room usable. If a week goes by without cleaning, the place becomes difficult to use even though no one has damaged the table or changed the room's rules. The table can be finished on Tuesday. The need to keep the room usable will return. Buying a machine that makes cleaning faster can reduce the hours people spend on that task. It does not give the activity a final completion point, and it tells us little about what people will do with the released time.
The prologue raises a harder version of the question through automation. Arendt asks what it would mean for a society organized around labor to be offered liberation from much labor. If the institutions through which people understand their time and place depend on that activity, having less of it leaves questions about how life is arranged. That is a political and conceptual problem even before we know how much any machine will do. The prologue poses it as a prospect and a paradox. The Human Condition, Prologue
Making a World That Can Be Shared
The table gives us an example of work in Arendt's narrower sense. The builder can select material in view of a form, carry through a sequence of steps and recognize when a usable object is ready. Once it is there, many people can use it without repeating the labor of making it. A scratch records a particular use. The object can serve people who know nothing about the person who made it. Its endurance gives the room a point of stability while the people and their immediate purposes change. The Human Condition, §§18–19
The table does not last forever. It belongs to the human world in Arendt's sense because it can endure through some succession of uses and users. She illustrates a related feature of public life by comparing the world to a table that sits between those gathered around it. A common object both connects people and lets them occupy different positions in relation to it. They can address one another about the table or about what takes place there. Their sharing of a world makes those distinct positions possible to recognize. The Human Condition, §7
Now imagine the room is demolished and the group moves to a different street. A new place may still afford the same activities. For the people who used the first room, the change can affect more than convenience. They may lose objects around which they remembered particular encounters or came to understand where they stood in relation to others. Someone who arrives afterwards can hear these accounts but cannot test them against the arrangement of the first room. Arendt’s account of the durability of the world lets us ask what common points of reference survive the move and what would have to be established anew.
This gives people a reason to care about what a place preserves. A noticeboard or a written record can allow someone who was absent to find out what the group decided. They can then come back with a different account of what was at stake. The things people make provide some continuity between those occasions. At the same time, their function can change. The group can stop keeping a record, move the table, or use it for a purpose the builder never considered. Its ability to hold a relation in place depends partly on what people actually do with it.
Arendt examines the limits of taking the maker's relation to an object as a model for every activity. When we make a table, the desired end can help us choose the wood, the joints and the tools. We can try to make the materials obey the design. If we try to treat a political community in the same way, independent responses begin to look like defects in a material that needs to be controlled. People can then be treated as means to an arrangement that has already been decided. The model loses precisely the feature Arendt wants to understand in action, the capacity of others to begin something of their own. The Human Condition, §§21 and 31
Starting Something Among Others
Suppose the first person to propose a new use of the room expects a yes-or-no vote. A visitor challenges the terms of the question. Another person suggests sharing access on different days and takes responsibility for drafting an agreement. Their exchange now includes an undertaking the proposer could not have planned alone. What each participant does enters into what the others can do next. It matters who is willing to introduce a suggestion, accept responsibility or answer an objection. Arendt calls attention to the way speech and action can disclose who a person is to others. A description of the person's job or skills does little to tell us who will make which intervention. The Human Condition, §§24–25
Two ideas ground this aspect of the book. Arendt associates the capacity to begin with natality, the fact that people are born and enter a world already inhabited by others. A newcomer can start something that could not have been read off from the previous state of affairs. She associates action with plurality. People can understand one another as human beings and remain distinct, each able to respond from a position nobody else occupies in the same way. Unpredictability follows in part from those responses. Once the proposal enters a setting in which others can act, its author has given up control over everything it may lead to. The Human Condition, §§1, 24–26
The person who proposes shared access may help begin an agreement. Its eventual terms depend on what other people propose and undertake. A reader can use the example to distinguish beginning an action from authoring all of its consequences.
The space of appearance names the setting that takes shape when people appear to one another in speech and action. The room can support that space by giving people a stable place to meet. A building with a calendar can also be used to announce decisions made elsewhere, allowing the people seated at the table little power to alter the arrangements. The space is a relationship among those who act together. Arendt describes it as possible wherever people gather and as liable to disappear when their activity ends. The Human Condition, §28
In the same section, power is tied to people acting together. An individual can possess physical strength or command useful resources. A group has power in Arendt's sense when its members sustain the ability to act in concert. A grant of funding may make their project easier. It cannot by itself make the people act on a proposal together. This use of power makes it possible to ask how a group keeps an undertaking alive once the first meeting or the first visible success has passed.
Living With What Other People Can Do
An action can have consequences the actor cannot undo. A demand made openly may change another person's trust in the group before the original speaker realizes what happened. A decision may also have consequences nobody can predict in full. The people at the meeting can undertake to make room available for the next month. They cannot settle in advance every use of it or every disagreement likely to arise. The features that make a joint undertaking possible also make it difficult to control as a finished product.
Arendt treats forgiveness and promising as partial responses within action itself. Forgiveness can release people from being tied indefinitely to the consequences of a deed. Forgiveness leaves the fact of the deed intact. A promise makes a limited future commitment on which another person can act, even with plenty of events still uncertain. The person who promised to unlock the room on Saturday can give others some ground for planning. That promise is worth making because the person is bound by the undertaking amid circumstances that remain open. The Human Condition, §§33–34
This part of the argument helps us understand a different meaning of reliability from the one the table offers. A sound joint can keep two pieces of wood in place without needing to renew their agreement. In a promise, a person's conduct is at issue. They may have to keep their word under conditions different from those present when they gave it. If a person can respond to another's need or acknowledge an injury, the resulting continuity depends on a capacity for action as much as the initial proposal did. Such stability comes in pieces and can be lost.
Who Gets to Appear in Public?
Arendt looks at the Greek distinction between the household and the polis to explain a historical way of identifying the private and the public. In the account she examines, some people could appear in a sphere understood as one of freedom because the necessary work of life was assigned to a household. The arrangements that gave that separation a concrete form depended on exclusion. Readers can use her distinction to ask who gets time, security and a place to appear among others. The question matters in the meeting-room example. The people who clean it may have the least time to join its debates. A scene of visible public freedom can depend on unequal control of time outside it. The Human Condition, §§5–8
One way to press the objection is to ask what the people who maintain the place can say about its use. If their contribution gives them knowledge of the hours when people really arrive or the rules that make the work harder, their participation can change the substance of a decision. Their role is then intelligible both in relation to recurring needs and in relation to what they can initiate among others. The contrast matters because a group can quietly depend on what its members do while allowing only some of them to shape its public purposes.
A related objection concerns which concerns can enter public speech. The debates in the room might begin with a dispute about access, affordable food or the care that people have time to provide. That practical origin still leaves possibilities for a public action. People can give an account of a need, disagree over the existing arrangement and initiate something the group had not planned. The conceptual distinction between sustaining life and acting with others helps identify different features of this episode. A rigid division of topics would miss its movement from a need to an action.
The distinctions also help us ask whether the simplest invitation to participate is sufficient. If it takes someone all evening to keep the place open, asking that same person to use it for another meeting does not resolve the problem of access. If the lease can be terminated without warning, an undertaking may have little time in which to take shape. Material resources and maintenance can give a public more room to act. The analysis gains precision when a reader can say what is presently missing, whether it is time, a durable place, or the freedom to shape the terms of a decision.
Applying the Distinctions to One Case
Try following the activities at the shop for a week. For each activity, ask what would count as finishing it and who has the capacity to change its outcome. Notice what would have to be repeated the next day, what would still be there when no one was using it, and what depends on an open response. A particular event may bring several answers together. Someone could undertake to keep a key available while preparing a meal that has to be made fresh. The key may help a promise take effect. Keeping the elements clear shows how they depend on one another without forcing the whole episode into one class.
Then read the first section of the book alongside the account of the space of appearance. The first section introduces the conditions that give each activity its character. The later discussion lets us ask what material arrangements and relationships can keep the possibility of action open. People may need the shop, a table and reliable opening hours before the conversation can take place. What they begin in it remains a question of what the participants are able to do with one another. That question gives the book's distinctions their importance for ordinary political experience.
Further Reading
- Hannah Arendt, The Human Condition, Prologue and §1. Read the question about automation alongside the initial account of labor, work and action.
- Hannah Arendt, The Human Condition, §§24–28. Trace the shift from an agent's disclosure in action to the dependence of power on people acting together.
- Hannah Arendt, The Human Condition, §§33–34. Compare which difficulty forgiving and promising can address and the limits of each.
Join the discussionAsk a question or share what you learned.
Keep exploring
Reference
Citation details
Cite or share this article.

Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!