Labor, work, and action › Starting Something Among Others
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Labor, work, and action › Starting Something Among OthersSection view · Sections in this chapter4 / 8 ↓
Suppose the first person to propose a new use of the room expects a yes-or-no vote. A visitor challenges the terms of the question. Another person suggests sharing access on different days and takes responsibility for drafting an agreement. Their exchange now includes an undertaking the proposer could not have planned alone. What each participant does enters into what the others can do next. It matters who is willing to introduce a suggestion, accept responsibility or answer an objection. Arendt calls attention to the way speech and action can disclose who a person is to others. A description of the person's job or skills does little to tell us who will make which intervention. The Human Condition, §§24–25
Two ideas ground this aspect of the book. Arendt associates the capacity to begin with natality, the fact that people are born and enter a world already inhabited by others. A newcomer can start something that could not have been read off from the previous state of affairs. She associates action with plurality. People can understand one another as human beings and remain distinct, each able to respond from a position nobody else occupies in the same way. Unpredictability follows in part from those responses. Once the proposal enters a setting in which others can act, its author has given up control over everything it may lead to. The Human Condition, §§1, 24–26
The person who proposes shared access may help begin an agreement. Its eventual terms depend on what other people propose and undertake. A reader can use the example to distinguish beginning an action from authoring all of its consequences.
The space of appearance names the setting that takes shape when people appear to one another in speech and action. The room can support that space by giving people a stable place to meet. A building with a calendar can also be used to announce decisions made elsewhere, allowing the people seated at the table little power to alter the arrangements. The space is a relationship among those who act together. Arendt describes it as possible wherever people gather and as liable to disappear when their activity ends. The Human Condition, §28
In the same section, power is tied to people acting together. An individual can possess physical strength or command useful resources. A group has power in Arendt's sense when its members sustain the ability to act in concert. A grant of funding may make their project easier. It cannot by itself make the people act on a proposal together. This use of power makes it possible to ask how a group keeps an undertaking alive once the first meeting or the first visible success has passed.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!