Beauvoir's The Second Sex: Woman as Other

Michael BrenndoerferUpdated September 28, 202613 min read

Simone de Beauvoir's 1949 foundational feminist philosophy applying existentialist categories to analyze woman as 'Other' and the construction of femininity.

PhilosophyAll chapters
Reading tools Notes & comments
Notes & comments
Part 11 of 12Power, History, and Social Criticism
Chapter 131Becoming the other › Who gets to stand for a person in general?
Reading the full chapter · 7 sections · 13 min7 sections · 13 min

All 7 sections · 13 min read

Becoming the other › Who gets to stand for a person in general?Full chapter · Sections in this chapter1 / 7 ↓

Who gets to stand for a person in general?

In the introduction to The Second Sex, Simone de Beauvoir asks what it means that she has to begin an account of herself by saying she is a woman. She suggests that the men who present themselves as writers or philosophers ordinarily feel less pressure to announce that they are men. The curiosity is that a position within humanity can present itself as humanity in general. The other position then appears to need an explanation of its own. Beauvoir is interested in what happens when that asymmetry organizes a person's education, work, and expectations of the future. Beauvoir, The Second Sex, vol. I, introduction.

Her book appeared in French in 1949. The first volume, Facts and Myths, examines attempted explanations of women's condition, considers history, and studies images of women. The second, Lived Experience, takes up some of the ways a woman can encounter those conditions from childhood onward. The order matters. A book about what people have said women are could compare representations without asking what those representations do. A book about how a particular woman experiences the world could record the experience without asking how its conditions came to be. Beauvoir wants to understand the connection. The Second Sex, contents and vol. I, introduction.

The opening question concerns a category that purports to explain the people it classifies. A woman can be treated as an obvious example of femininity because she acts as others expect. Another might be told she is insufficiently feminine for failing to act the same way. The apparent nature is thus used to evaluate the people whose behavior is supposed to establish it. In the introduction Beauvoir also objects to an abstract declaration that everyone is simply human. That can be true while leaving differences in what people are allowed to do or expected to become unexamined. Her question is how a social position acquired the standing of a natural definition. The Second Sex, vol. I, introduction.

What it means to be made the Other

Beauvoir begins with ordinary ways a group distinguishes itself from others. People traveling abroad can call the people where they arrive foreigners. It is immediately possible for their hosts to describe the travelers as foreign too. The relation is reciprocal. Beauvoir asks why this reversal has been more difficult between women and men. A man's point of view can be treated as impartial or representative, while a woman's judgment is liable to be explained by her being a woman. The structure makes his position look unmarked while her position becomes a feature that has to account for everything she does. The Second Sex, vol. I, introduction.

The word Other names this asymmetry. Beauvoir draws on Hegel's account of a subject confronting other subjects, and also on examples from social anthropology. In the case she examines, one side is taken as the starting point from which the other is defined. Talk of woman as a mysterious category can already presuppose the position of a man for whom the alleged mystery is an obstacle. A woman continues to be a subject with projects, perceptions, and judgments of her own. Her subordination consists partly in being treated as secondary within a world she also inhabits. The Second Sex, vol. I, introduction and part III, ch. 1.

The introduction asks how such a relation could persist in societies in which women live and work alongside men. Economic dependence, household arrangements, marriage, and residence can all attach women to particular men. They also divide women from one another. Beauvoir explicitly observes that loyalties and interests can be organized by class and race as well as by sex. A woman may share significant advantages with men of her class while sharing little of the daily situation of women who do domestic work for her. These observations make collective action a question of material and social possibilities, even when people recognize a shared grievance. Some of the comparisons Beauvoir uses in making this point can flatten the historical differences between forms of subordination. Readers can test the comparisons separately from her question about how connections and dependencies shape recognition. The Second Sex, vol. I, introduction.

The Other

Beauvoir uses Otherness to describe a relation in which one position is treated as the general human standpoint and another is defined in relation to it. A woman can experience the world and pursue purposes as a subject even while the surrounding institutions treat her standpoint as secondary.

The body as a situation

The chapter on biology makes a distinction between living a body and assigning a destiny from the outside. Bodies make activities possible and give them limits. A person can encounter changing physical demands or experience a capacity as a source of pleasure or difficulty. Beauvoir asks what those facts can tell us about a hierarchy of social possibilities. The meaning of a physical capacity depends on what a community values, how it organizes work, and whether its practices give that capacity much practical weight. A difference in strength, for example, takes on different significance depending on the work, the tools available, and which tasks come with authority. The Second Sex, vol. I, part I, ch. 1, “The Data of Biology”.

Beauvoir uses situation for the conditions from within which freedom is exercised. In the biology chapter the body is part of one's practical contact with the world. A bodily fact can matter to the person living it while failing to explain why a law, a custom, or the division of labor should make that fact consequential in a particular way. People can respond actively to a situation even when they have little power to alter it. This gives readers a way to consider the lived body and the conditions that give it practical significance together. The chapter's period claims about physiology are distinct from that philosophical argument. The Second Sex, vol. I, part I, ch. 1.

Beauvoir reviews psychoanalysis and historical materialism for different reasons. She allows that someone's attachments and anxieties are important to the way they experience their body. She asks why a physical difference that appears in those experiences was assigned prestige or shame to begin with, and why familiar accounts can take a male subject's development as the standard. Historical materialism draws attention to the means of production, property, and the organization of labor. Beauvoir asks whether these factors alone explain why particular ways of owning, valuing, and controlling were taken up. The common question to both accounts is what has been assumed about how the people described could experience and act in their world. The Second Sex, vol. I, part I, chs. 2–3.

Learning to become a woman

The chapter on childhood opens with the claim that a person becomes a woman. The following lines put the emphasis on the social world that helps produce the figure it calls feminine. Beauvoir studies how increasing restrictions, praise, and advice can change a child's experience of what she can do. She pays particular attention to the relationship between the activities children are allowed or encouraged to pursue and the ways they are invited to see themselves. A girl who learns that climbing will be treated as unbecoming may stop climbing. Her reluctance could then be cited as evidence that girls simply prefer other pursuits. The example illustrates how training can make its own effects look like a starting point. The Second Sex, vol. II, “Childhood,” H. M. Parshley translation.

Think of two children learning to walk through a busy place. If one is consistently encouraged to explore and the other is repeatedly warned about attracting attention, each can come to anticipate a different response to the same act. The distinction can matter before either child can explain it. There is an acquired sense of what is available and what incurs a cost. Beauvoir's discussion makes room for activity on the child's part. Lessons about where to go, what to wear, and how to behave can be taken up, imitated, tested, or resisted. The experience is shaped through that traffic between what the child tries and how others respond.

The concern is broader than adding social expectations to a body that already has a fixed meaning. Consider the physical sensation of getting stronger as you practice a task. In one situation it can become a basis for confidence and further projects. In another, a girl can learn to conceal the same strength or to see the desire to use it as something she needs to excuse. The useful question for Beauvoir is how people come to live their capacities under such different descriptions. Her account in Lived Experience moves from childhood and adolescence to sexual life and adult positions that do not follow one uniform course. The Second Sex, vol. II, “Childhood” and contents.

What myths do with a real person

Volume I examines myths through situations in which a representation of women promises something to its maker. Beauvoir reads the story of Eve's creation as an example. In her account of the story, Eve originates from Adam and is given to him, so what she is for can be told as part of his story. She uses the example to show how an image makes a person's dependence look like the reason for her existence. This is her reading of the myth, distinct from a claim about the only way it has been read or a complete explanation of why any actual marriage is organized in a certain way. The Second Sex, vol. I, part III, ch. 1.

A myth can both celebrate women and reserve subjecthood for men. Suppose a story presents one character as the sole source of comfort and constancy in another person's adventures. The praise can be sincere. The character praised can still appear almost exclusively at the points where her help is needed. If you then ask what an adventure of hers would be, the story may have very little to say. Beauvoir brings a similar question to competing myths of purity, flesh, care, and danger. The representations do not have to agree as portraits. They can answer different hopes and fears for the person who sees himself as their central subject. The Second Sex, vol. I, part III, ch. 1.

This also shows why myth belongs alongside an account of wages, household work, or education. A woman can discover that she has less access to a kind of work. She can also hear that the division expresses something deeper about what she finds fulfilling. The claim can present restrictions as evidence of a shared purpose when only one side was able to develop the arrangement. Beauvoir's method lets us ask what independence or initiative would mean on the woman's side of the account. It also keeps favorable images open to question, since praise for dedication can obscure an absence of opportunities to do something else.

What freedom requires

In the introduction Beauvoir calls the pursuit of an open project transcendence. Immanence names a condition in which this movement is arrested and existence is confined to what has already been assigned. The contrast does more than sort activities into exciting ones and repetitive ones. A task can be worthwhile in an arrangement that gives the people doing it room to reconsider their commitments, and can become oppressive where it is imposed as the only kind of life available. Beauvoir describes imposed immanence as oppression and insists that women in such a situation are subjects whose freedom is constrained. The Second Sex, vol. I, introduction.

A reader can ask whether this vocabulary does enough justice to the value of maintaining a home, caring for a child, or keeping a group alive over time. Those activities can involve judgment, skilled improvisation, invention, and purposes recognizable as one's own. Beauvoir's question about the chances of pursuing other projects can be asked alongside those facts. Imagine two people who both value caring for a relative. One can combine it with paid work, share it with others, and choose how much to undertake. The other has much less say in when care is required and what else is possible. Describing both people simply as devoted misses a difference the concept of situation brings into view.

The book addresses the same difficulty with economic independence. Earning an income can give a woman means to act that legal permission alone does not supply. Beauvoir's historical discussion also describes harsh work that leaves a woman with very little effective independence after all. The organization of the work, its returns, and the other burdens she carries matter to what it makes possible. In a later interview she returns to the gap between formal equality and the practical conditions needed to change power in households and public life. That retrospect gives a reader another way to see the question driving the inquiry. The Second Sex, vol. I, part II, historical discussion. Beauvoir, 1976 interview.

In that interview, Beauvoir describes women at the Lip factory whose role changed during a strike. In her telling, husbands initially helped with the dispute. Some objected once the women wanted to share the work of guarding the factory at night on equal terms with the men. The women could find support in the labor dispute and come into conflict over household authority as the work of the strike changed. This is a later example offered by Beauvoir, not evidence on which the 1949 book relied. It sharpens the problem the earlier introduction raises. Whether people will be able to stand together depends partly on which conflicts they encounter together and how the arrangements of daily life react to their doing so. Beauvoir, 1976 interview, on the Lip strike.

When Beauvoir asks what makes a woman's freedom possible, she also asks who gets to determine whether an arrangement is good for her. The introduction distrusts comparisons that declare people happy in a place others chose for them. Happiness can be real within narrow circumstances and can matter greatly to the person living there. It tells us little by itself about which paths are open, what pursuing a different path would cost, and whether a person can enter relations in which her judgment counts. Those are questions Beauvoir thinks a social arrangement has to answer. The Second Sex, vol. I, introduction.

The two volumes are also an invitation to read an explanation from more than one standpoint. A description of a household as orderly may be accurate about whether the work gets done. A description of the same household from the person doing it can reveal whose plans are adjustable and whose are taken as fixed. Neither observation alone establishes how the arrangement arose. Together they help turn a claim about femininity into questions about the opportunities people actually have.

Further reading

Join the discussionAsk a question or share what you learned.

Comments

Add to the conversation

A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!

A different angle
All writing
Philosophy

Arendt's The Origins of Totalitarianism: Understanding Political Evil

Hannah Arendt's 1951 essential work for understanding twentieth-century political catastrophe as a novel form of evil, analyzing antisemitism, imperialism, and totalitarian movements.

13 min read
Philosophy

Arendt's The Human Condition: Labor, Work, and Action

Hannah Arendt's 1958 original analysis of labor, work, and action that distinguishes genuine political action from mere behavior and recovers the vita activa.

13 min read
Philosophy

Marx and Engels’s Communist Manifesto: Class and Political Action

Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels’s 1848 pamphlet traces the rise of wage labor, the organization of workers, and the struggle over who controls production.

13 min read

About the author

Reference

Citation details

Cite or share this article.

BIBTEXAcademic
@misc{brenndoerfer2026beauvoirs, author = {Michael Brenndoerfer}, title = {Beauvoir's The Second Sex: Woman as Other}, year = {2026}, url = {https://mbrenndoerfer.com/writing/beauvoir-second-sex-feminist-philosophy-other-guide}, organization = {mbrenndoerfer.com}, note = {Accessed: 2026-11-19} }
APAAcademic
Michael Brenndoerfer (2026). Beauvoir's The Second Sex: Woman as Other. Retrieved from https://mbrenndoerfer.com/writing/beauvoir-second-sex-feminist-philosophy-other-guide
MLAAcademic
Michael Brenndoerfer. "Beauvoir's The Second Sex: Woman as Other." 2026. Web. November 19, 2026. <https://mbrenndoerfer.com/writing/beauvoir-second-sex-feminist-philosophy-other-guide>.
CHICAGOAcademic
Michael Brenndoerfer. "Beauvoir's The Second Sex: Woman as Other." Accessed November 19, 2026. https://mbrenndoerfer.com/writing/beauvoir-second-sex-feminist-philosophy-other-guide.
HARVARDAcademic
Michael Brenndoerfer (2026) 'Beauvoir's The Second Sex: Woman as Other'. Available at: https://mbrenndoerfer.com/writing/beauvoir-second-sex-feminist-philosophy-other-guide (Accessed: November 19, 2026).
SimpleBasic
Michael Brenndoerfer (2026). Beauvoir's The Second Sex: Woman as Other. https://mbrenndoerfer.com/writing/beauvoir-second-sex-feminist-philosophy-other-guide
Newsletter

Stay up to date

Get new articles, book updates, and notes on AI and technology.

Unsubscribe at any time. Privacy policy