Becoming the other › Learning to become a woman
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Becoming the other › Learning to become a womanSection view · Sections in this chapter4 / 7 ↓
The chapter on childhood opens with the claim that a person becomes a woman. The following lines put the emphasis on the social world that helps produce the figure it calls feminine. Beauvoir studies how increasing restrictions, praise, and advice can change a child's experience of what she can do. She pays particular attention to the relationship between the activities children are allowed or encouraged to pursue and the ways they are invited to see themselves. A girl who learns that climbing will be treated as unbecoming may stop climbing. Her reluctance could then be cited as evidence that girls simply prefer other pursuits. The example illustrates how training can make its own effects look like a starting point. The Second Sex, vol. II, “Childhood,” H. M. Parshley translation.
Think of two children learning to walk through a busy place. If one is consistently encouraged to explore and the other is repeatedly warned about attracting attention, each can come to anticipate a different response to the same act. The distinction can matter before either child can explain it. There is an acquired sense of what is available and what incurs a cost. Beauvoir's discussion makes room for activity on the child's part. Lessons about where to go, what to wear, and how to behave can be taken up, imitated, tested, or resisted. The experience is shaped through that traffic between what the child tries and how others respond.
The concern is broader than adding social expectations to a body that already has a fixed meaning. Consider the physical sensation of getting stronger as you practice a task. In one situation it can become a basis for confidence and further projects. In another, a girl can learn to conceal the same strength or to see the desire to use it as something she needs to excuse. The useful question for Beauvoir is how people come to live their capacities under such different descriptions. Her account in Lived Experience moves from childhood and adolescence to sexual life and adult positions that do not follow one uniform course. The Second Sex, vol. II, “Childhood” and contents.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!