Becoming the other › Who gets to stand for a person in general?
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Becoming the other › Who gets to stand for a person in general?Section view · Sections in this chapter1 / 7 ↓
In the introduction to The Second Sex, Simone de Beauvoir asks what it means that she has to begin an account of herself by saying she is a woman. She suggests that the men who present themselves as writers or philosophers ordinarily feel less pressure to announce that they are men. The curiosity is that a position within humanity can present itself as humanity in general. The other position then appears to need an explanation of its own. Beauvoir is interested in what happens when that asymmetry organizes a person's education, work, and expectations of the future. Beauvoir, The Second Sex, vol. I, introduction.
Her book appeared in French in 1949. The first volume, Facts and Myths, examines attempted explanations of women's condition, considers history, and studies images of women. The second, Lived Experience, takes up some of the ways a woman can encounter those conditions from childhood onward. The order matters. A book about what people have said women are could compare representations without asking what those representations do. A book about how a particular woman experiences the world could record the experience without asking how its conditions came to be. Beauvoir wants to understand the connection. The Second Sex, contents and vol. I, introduction.
The opening question concerns a category that purports to explain the people it classifies. A woman can be treated as an obvious example of femininity because she acts as others expect. Another might be told she is insufficiently feminine for failing to act the same way. The apparent nature is thus used to evaluate the people whose behavior is supposed to establish it. In the introduction Beauvoir also objects to an abstract declaration that everyone is simply human. That can be true while leaving differences in what people are allowed to do or expected to become unexamined. Her question is how a social position acquired the standing of a natural definition. The Second Sex, vol. I, introduction.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!