Becoming the other › What freedom requires
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Becoming the other › What freedom requiresSection view · Sections in this chapter6 / 7 ↓
In the introduction Beauvoir calls the pursuit of an open project transcendence. Immanence names a condition in which this movement is arrested and existence is confined to what has already been assigned. The contrast does more than sort activities into exciting ones and repetitive ones. A task can be worthwhile in an arrangement that gives the people doing it room to reconsider their commitments, and can become oppressive where it is imposed as the only kind of life available. Beauvoir describes imposed immanence as oppression and insists that women in such a situation are subjects whose freedom is constrained. The Second Sex, vol. I, introduction.
A reader can ask whether this vocabulary does enough justice to the value of maintaining a home, caring for a child, or keeping a group alive over time. Those activities can involve judgment, skilled improvisation, invention, and purposes recognizable as one's own. Beauvoir's question about the chances of pursuing other projects can be asked alongside those facts. Imagine two people who both value caring for a relative. One can combine it with paid work, share it with others, and choose how much to undertake. The other has much less say in when care is required and what else is possible. Describing both people simply as devoted misses a difference the concept of situation brings into view.
The book addresses the same difficulty with economic independence. Earning an income can give a woman means to act that legal permission alone does not supply. Beauvoir's historical discussion also describes harsh work that leaves a woman with very little effective independence after all. The organization of the work, its returns, and the other burdens she carries matter to what it makes possible. In a later interview she returns to the gap between formal equality and the practical conditions needed to change power in households and public life. That retrospect gives a reader another way to see the question driving the inquiry. The Second Sex, vol. I, part II, historical discussion. Beauvoir, 1976 interview.
In that interview, Beauvoir describes women at the Lip factory whose role changed during a strike. In her telling, husbands initially helped with the dispute. Some objected once the women wanted to share the work of guarding the factory at night on equal terms with the men. The women could find support in the labor dispute and come into conflict over household authority as the work of the strike changed. This is a later example offered by Beauvoir, not evidence on which the 1949 book relied. It sharpens the problem the earlier introduction raises. Whether people will be able to stand together depends partly on which conflicts they encounter together and how the arrangements of daily life react to their doing so. Beauvoir, 1976 interview, on the Lip strike.
When Beauvoir asks what makes a woman's freedom possible, she also asks who gets to determine whether an arrangement is good for her. The introduction distrusts comparisons that declare people happy in a place others chose for them. Happiness can be real within narrow circumstances and can matter greatly to the person living there. It tells us little by itself about which paths are open, what pursuing a different path would cost, and whether a person can enter relations in which her judgment counts. Those are questions Beauvoir thinks a social arrangement has to answer. The Second Sex, vol. I, introduction.
The two volumes are also an invitation to read an explanation from more than one standpoint. A description of a household as orderly may be accurate about whether the work gets done. A description of the same household from the person doing it can reveal whose plans are adjustable and whose are taken as fixed. Neither observation alone establishes how the arrangement arose. Together they help turn a claim about femininity into questions about the opportunities people actually have.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!