Labor, work, and action › Living With What Other People Can Do
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Labor, work, and action › Living With What Other People Can DoSection view · Sections in this chapter5 / 8 ↓
An action can have consequences the actor cannot undo. A demand made openly may change another person's trust in the group before the original speaker realizes what happened. A decision may also have consequences nobody can predict in full. The people at the meeting can undertake to make room available for the next month. They cannot settle in advance every use of it or every disagreement likely to arise. The features that make a joint undertaking possible also make it difficult to control as a finished product.
Arendt treats forgiveness and promising as partial responses within action itself. Forgiveness can release people from being tied indefinitely to the consequences of a deed. Forgiveness leaves the fact of the deed intact. A promise makes a limited future commitment on which another person can act, even with plenty of events still uncertain. The person who promised to unlock the room on Saturday can give others some ground for planning. That promise is worth making because the person is bound by the undertaking amid circumstances that remain open. The Human Condition, §§33–34
This part of the argument helps us understand a different meaning of reliability from the one the table offers. A sound joint can keep two pieces of wood in place without needing to renew their agreement. In a promise, a person's conduct is at issue. They may have to keep their word under conditions different from those present when they gave it. If a person can respond to another's need or acknowledge an injury, the resulting continuity depends on a capacity for action as much as the initial proposal did. Such stability comes in pieces and can be lost.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!