Commodities, labor, and accumulation › What Relations Between Things Can Tell Us
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Commodities, labor, and accumulation › What Relations Between Things Can Tell UsSection view · Sections in this chapter6 / 8 ↓
If tailors and weavers produce independently for exchange, they find out through exchanges whether others will take their products on the proposed terms. Their labor is interdependent in a practical sense. The weaver needs articles produced by other people and must exchange some of the cloth to obtain them. The amounts of cloth and coats brought to the market affect the possibilities open to both producers. Each encounters part of a social relationship among producers in the form of relations among their products. That way of encountering the relationship is what Marx asks us to attend to in the section on commodity fetishism. Capital, volume I, chapter 1, §4
A person can know every step in making a coat and still have to wait to see whether the finished coat will exchange as expected. Even producers with detailed knowledge about others' work deal with circumstances that come back to them through relations between products. Thus the analysis concerns the organization of production and exchange. It reaches beyond a person's failure to imagine the work behind the goods on a shop shelf. For Marx it matters that the relations acquire an objective form that participants have to reckon with, whatever they privately believe about the objects.
This returns us to the spinner's employer. The person can keep careful accounts of purchases and sales. If the problem is the expansion of value in the example, the figures need to be interpreted in relation to a division of the working day and to whoever has the authority to direct the labor. If the problem is how the growth of an enterprise becomes sustainable, the next entries will concern what the owner can buy with the surplus and under what conditions. Each question gives familiar entries in the accounts a different role.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!