Commodities, labor, and accumulation › Keeping Track of the Spinner's Day

Michael BrenndoerferUpdated April 20, 20264 min read
PhilosophyAll chapters
Reading tools Notes & comments
Notes & comments
Part 11 of 12Power, History, and Social Criticism
Chapter 128Commodities, labor, and accumulation › Keeping Track of the Spinner's Day
Reading section 4 of 8 · Keeping Track of the Spinner's Day · 4 minSection 4 of 8 · 4 min

Section 4 of 8 · 4 min read

Commodities, labor, and accumulation › Keeping Track of the Spinner's DaySection view · Sections in this chapter4 / 8 ↓

Marx works through quantities in the spinning example in chapter 7. In the longer of two cases, the cotton and used-up portion of the spindle contribute 24 shillings to the finished yarn. A day's labor-power was bought for 3 shillings. The spinner's labor adds 6 shillings. The total laid out for that batch is 27 shillings, and the total value of the yarn is 30 shillings. When the finished yarn sells at that value, the difference is 3 shillings. The example includes the input values already present in the cotton and spindle. The new value is the 6 shillings added by the spinner, of which 3 replace the amount advanced for labor-power. Capital, volume I, chapter 7, §2

We can show the distinction with a separate example expressed in labor-hours. Assume that each hour adds the same amount of new value in both an eight-hour shift and a ten-hour shift. If four hours replace the value of the day's labor-power, four hours of surplus labor remain. The rate of surplus value in that example is the surplus divided by the amount replacing the value of labor-power. Four divided by four is one, or 100 percent. If the shift increases to ten hours and the replacement time remains four hours, six hours are surplus. Six divided by four is 150 percent. The change in the rate in this example comes entirely from two additional hours worked under the stipulated conditions.

The Denominator Matters

In the eight-hour example, surplus labor takes up half the shift. The rate of surplus value is 100 percent because Marx compares surplus with necessary labor, which takes up the other half. A profit rate calculated on total capital advanced would use a different denominator.

In chapter 9, Marx calls the value laid out on the means of production constant capital. He calls the part laid out on labor-power variable capital. In his accounting, cotton passes its existing value into the yarn, and the spindle transfers the value corresponding to the portion used up. The spinner adds new value. To find the rate of surplus value, look at the relation between the resulting surplus and the amount laid out on labor-power. This ratio answers a question about the division of new value. It differs from the share of sales revenue left after recording all the costs of a business. Capital, volume I, chapter 9, §1

Consider also a change in productivity with the length of the shift held fixed. Suppose it makes the means of workers' subsistence cheaper in value terms. If labor-power is still bought at its value, the portion of the shift needed to reproduce that value may fall. At an unchanged rate at which living labor adds new value, the remainder of the same shift then represents a larger surplus. The condition on the means of subsistence matters. A faster way to make an article outside the relevant bundle of goods would not by itself establish that effect. This is one reason to track which process has changed when examining a proposed rise in the rate.

The example's arithmetic can be correct while its premises remain contested. A reader can ask what establishes the proposed connection between social working time and value. Another question concerns the relationship between an analysis of the production of surplus and the price at which a particular capital can sell its output. Neither matter is decided by subtracting 27 shillings from 30. By following the separate entries in the example, we can see which claim we would need to challenge or defend in order to address a specific objection.

Comments

Add to the conversation

A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!

Newsletter

Stay up to date

Get new articles, book updates, and notes on AI and technology.

Unsubscribe at any time. Privacy policy