Class and political conflict › Why the Later Sections Debate Other Programs
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Class and political conflict › Why the Later Sections Debate Other ProgramsSection view · Sections in this chapter5 / 7 ↓
The authors devote section III to kinds of socialist and communist writing they criticize. The distinctions matter because writers can agree that industrial conditions are severe and disagree about what to do about them. The Manifesto treats the wish to restore older social arrangements differently from a program that proposes remedies within bourgeois society. It also credits earlier socialist critics with making aspects of the existing society visible while objecting to strategies that expect exemplary communities or appeals to society at large to deliver a transformation. Those polemical descriptions are the authors' assessment of their rivals. We can use the distinctions to ask what an argument for change expects to move the people who could carry it out. Manifesto, section III
Section IV discusses cooperation with other opposition movements. In the discussion of Germany, for instance, it allows cooperation with the bourgeoisie against absolute monarchy and other forces of the old order while insisting that workers understand their eventual conflict with the bourgeoisie itself. One reason to read this section after the account of class is that it shows how agreement over a particular political goal can coexist with disagreement about what should come next. Allies can share an interest in removing a barrier while having very different plans for the institutions that replace it. Political organization has to account for both facts. Manifesto, section IV
There is a similar distinction in the discussion of ideas in section II. Marx and Engels link changes in prevailing ideas to changes in material and social relations. An interpretation of that claim should specify the connection it proposes. Consider a dispute about who gets to direct an enterprise. A legal vocabulary of ownership can make one party's authority seem like an ordinary consequence of property. The same parties might defend their positions differently once the rules allow workers to participate in decisions. Recognizing a connection between rules and the ways people justify authority still leaves us free to examine individual arguments and to say why some succeed or fail.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!