Class and political conflict › What the Authors Mean by Abolishing Bourgeois Property
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Class and political conflict › What the Authors Mean by Abolishing Bourgeois PropertySection view · Sections in this chapter4 / 7 ↓
A family that uses a stove and an owner who uses a factory both possess things. Both might have legally protected claims. Yet property in a factory can give the owner the authority to employ people and exercise control over their work. Section II singles out the historically specific form of property that enables a class to exercise this power. In replying to the charge that they want to end all appropriation, Marx and Engels say the objection concerns the social means by which some gain power over the labor of others. People can still take and use what they need to live in the society the authors envision. Manifesto, section II
The distinction also helps explain why an individual owner's intentions carry limited weight in the analysis. Imagine that one business owner takes pains to treat employees well. If the business still depends on the owner's authority to decide how the equipment will be used and on the employees' need to sell their capacity to work, the relationship analyzed by the text persists. The normative question is what powers people should have over productive resources and over the terms under which others use them. That can be asked even when the particular people involved have done nothing wrong by the ordinary rules of the enterprise.
Marx and Engels give their program an immediate political aim. They call for the proletariat to constitute itself as a political class and win political power. The transitional measures near the end of section II address matters such as land, taxation, credit and education. The text says that the measures will vary from country to country. Its 1872 German preface, written after the Paris Commune, explains that the program's specific steps would be framed differently in light of subsequent experience. In particular, the authors qualify what it would mean for the working class to use existing state machinery. The distinction between the end of the transformation and the measures adopted along the way is present from the start and becomes explicit when they revisit the book. Manifesto, section II and 1872 preface
The section's account of the projected end gives the free development of individuals a central place. Its claim is that the development of each is to be a condition for the development of all. A difficulty for the program is to explain how collective authority over production would secure that development. Suppose a group gains the power to set the terms of access to the workshop. Who can challenge its decisions, and how might people who need the workshop get a hearing? The text gives an aim by which to judge the transformation. It leaves considerable work to anyone trying to work out an institutional form that meets that aim.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!