Progress and the claims of the past › The Work Buried Inside a Cultural Treasure
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Progress and the claims of the past › The Work Buried Inside a Cultural TreasureSection view · Sections in this chapter3 / 7 ↓
Thesis VII imagines victors passing on what they have won in a triumphal procession. Cultural treasures are among the things they carry. An achievement may owe its existence to skilled makers and to less visible labor performed under harsh conditions. Its later preservation and transfer can also reproduce relations of power. Benjamin asks a historian to pay attention to both its making and the way it came down to us.
Imagine the authorized history of a public building. It names the architect, describes the opening ceremony, and shows the people who commissioned it. Those details can all be accurate. If the history records the names and designs that entered the public record while leaving the conditions of construction unexamined, it can repeat the standpoint from which the building was celebrated. A different account would use information about who worked on it, what they could refuse, and how the site came to be available. There is no need to stop looking at the architecture to ask about those conditions.
Benjamin calls the task reading history against the grain. It demands attention to the means by which some experiences and achievements become visible and others recede. Someone whose name is missing from the register may have had much to do with the thing the register celebrates. The absence of that person's record can itself become a question about how the register was made. Recognizing a silence does not tell us what to put in its place. It tells us why further historical work is needed.
The angle on cultural inheritance also matters for the historian's sympathies. Benjamin argues that an easy identification with the victors benefits those in power in the present. An account can inherit an allegiance even while it strives to reproduce past events faithfully. One way to examine that allegiance is to ask whose success makes the story cohere, and which losses it asks the reader to accept as the cost of an achievement. The building requires a different description once those questions are allowed to interrupt the story of its completion.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!