Progress and the claims of the past › A Memory Becomes Legible in a Moment of Danger
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Progress and the claims of the past › A Memory Becomes Legible in a Moment of DangerSection view · Sections in this chapter4 / 7 ↓
In theses V–VI, Benjamin describes the past through an image that can flash into recognition. The image appears in a present where it matters and may be lost if that present fails to recognize the connection. A moment of danger can threaten both a tradition and the people who inherit it. The risk is that the tradition will be reshaped to serve those who dominate it.
A particular record might be preserved for years and come to matter in a new way when a conflict returns. Imagine minutes describing workers' opposition to a safety practice. A later manager cites the minutes as evidence that employees were consulted. In another moment, workers facing a related danger might see them as evidence of an unresolved objection. The words in the minutes have not changed. Their use and the questions through which they become legible have changed. The example illustrates what can be at stake in retrieving a record rather than merely preserving it.
Benjamin's rejection of the historian's claim to describe the past simply as it really was does not turn the record into evidence for whatever we wish to say. A historical account can be wrong about what happened, who acted, and what was possible then. The question he raises is what gives the surviving trace its significance for a historian in a particular present. A later struggle can help make previously overlooked evidence intelligible. It can also generate temptations to make the past say too much. How a reading treats the actual record remains important for telling those cases apart.
Thesis II gives the relation to the past a name. Benjamin speaks of a weak messianic power held by each generation, on which the past has a claim. Notice the direction of the claim. The present inherits unfinished matters for which it can become answerable. The scope of its power is limited. The historian cannot literally give a different life to the dead, any more than the angel can undo the wreckage as it is driven away. Yet what the present remembers and carries forward can still make a difference to the defeat or appropriation of what earlier people attempted.
Thesis XII puts this in a political register. Benjamin contrasts motivations drawn from the memory of people already subjected to oppression with an assurance that later generations will be free. The example explains why he objects to imagining emancipation as the normal result of a long process. An expectation about the future can be morally powerful. It gives a different reason for acting from a memory of injury and a sense of what the present still owes.
The description of historical materialism in thesis IV complicates the idea that the materialist historian simply records who took control of land, food, or tools. These are real matters at stake in class struggle. Benjamin also names qualities such as courage and humor that can be present in struggle without being possessions captured by whichever side wins. An unsuccessful effort can show what people were able to imagine or do together even though they did not change who held power. A later observer can see that effort without being able to regard it as a victory.
This is one reason to be careful about what a history of failure records. An account organized around the outcome may tell us only that a group's demands were refused. There may be evidence about forms of organization, mutual support, and judgment that developed through making the demands. These can matter again although the group's objective remained out of reach. The distinction helps preserve what people did without telling a compensatory story in which their failure had to happen for someone else's later success.
Thesis III offers a perspective in which events do not have to be treated as inherently too small to remember. Benjamin casts the prospect of a past citable in all its moments in the theological register of redemption and the Last Judgment. A working historian still has to select questions and evidence. The passage makes it possible to ask what authorizes the starting division between events the historian has a reason to consider and events already written off. The apparent smallness of a thing in the received account may tell us more about how the account was assembled than about the thing itself.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!