Progress and the claims of the past › Why Progress Can Be a Bad Explanation
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Progress and the claims of the past › Why Progress Can Be a Bad ExplanationSection view · Sections in this chapter2 / 7 ↓
In thesis XIII, Benjamin criticizes a view of progress he associates with social democratic theory and practice. It treats progress as the improvement of humanity itself, as unending, and as essentially unstoppable. His objection goes deeper than denying any one of those attributes. They share a conception of time in which progress can be imagined as continuing through a sequence of uniform moments. Benjamin calls it homogeneous, empty time.
Ordinary chronology is indispensable for many historical questions. We need dates to know whether a law was passed before or after a strike and to establish which decisions people could have responded to. Benjamin's target is the story that can be put on that sequence, as if its forward movement by itself told us how humanity is doing. One can register changes in knowledge and productive capacity without assuming they carry everyone toward emancipation. The angel gives the failure of that assumption a visual form.
In thesis VIII, the history of oppressed people supplies a different measure of what counts as ordinary. A condition experienced as an emergency can be recurrent or customary from their point of view. If we treat their experiences as exceptions, we may suppose the main course of history is making such things increasingly impossible. Benjamin asks what happens when the advance of fascism makes that conviction untenable. The surprise that such things are still possible tells us something about the idea of history that made us surprised.
Benjamin uses the language of an emergency twice in that thesis. One use concerns the condition the oppressed know as the rule. The other concerns a real interruption to be brought about in the struggle against fascism. Simply announcing that the ordinary course of things has been suspended would not make the two uses equivalent. We have to ask whose ordinary course is in view and what the interruption is meant to change. The link to action makes this more than a question about whether progress is a good name for the past.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!