The conditions of a human life › Where Sen and Nussbaum Part Company
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
The conditions of a human life › Where Sen and Nussbaum Part CompanySection view · Sections in this chapter6 / 9 ↓
Nussbaum discusses Amartya Sen's work directly in Women and Human Development, Introduction §III. Both take an interest in the opportunities people have rather than trying to assess a life by resources or reported satisfaction alone. Sen's use of the framework helps compare the quality and justice of people's lives and can leave open which capabilities are most relevant for a particular evaluation. Nussbaum defends a specified list in the service of a more particular project. She wants to say what political entitlements governments should secure for each person.
The difference can be tested with a policy comparison. If we want to ask which transport plan creates more opportunities, we might select the dimensions most relevant to that question and leave other capabilities in the background. If we want to ask whether there are any areas in which public institutions are failing people at the level of basic justice, Nussbaum thinks we need greater assurance that our selection will not omit an important claim. The minimum helps structure the second inquiry. Both inquiries can draw on much of the same evidence.
In “Human Rights and Human Capabilities”, she explains that this account has affinities with the protection of human rights, especially when a right is understood through the institutions and material conditions needed to use it. A right to political participation does little work for someone prevented from getting information or reaching the place where decisions are made. Looking for what makes the right effective adds a question about the public responsibilities its protection entails.
This also helps explain why the proposal grants people room to choose. If someone declines to exercise a capability, that may express their values. If they have learned that they are unlikely to be allowed to exercise it, a report of indifference may tell us something about the world they have faced. Imagine a person who says there is no point in applying for a position never offered to anyone like them. We can take the statement seriously without treating it as sufficient evidence that they have no interest in the opportunity. Whether applying becomes a live option is a separate question from what they eventually choose.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!