Difference and structural injustice › Who Gets Heard When the Bus Route Changes?
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Difference and structural injustice › Who Gets Heard When the Bus Route Changes?Section view · Sections in this chapter1 / 9 ↓
Suppose a city proposes spending the same amount per resident on transit in every neighborhood. At a public meeting, most comments are about money and the location of stops. A resident wants to explain that a route passed as accessible still cannot be used on their shift. The buses that can take their wheelchair do not run at the times they need them. They can submit a written statement, but the council will have fixed the schedule before staff review it. An equal allocation could coexist with a decision process that gives some residents little chance to explain what access requires.
In Justice and the Politics of Difference, first published in 1990, Iris Marion Young asks what we miss when we expect justice to be understood primarily as distribution. The transit example contains ordinary distributive questions. The budget and the supply of accessible buses matter. But deciding who participates, what evidence enters an agenda, and which routines count as normal also affects whether people can use a public service. Those decisions are part of the object of an inquiry into justice.
Young's alternative starts from institutional conditions that enable or inhibit people in developing and exercising capacities, communicating, and acting with others. Chapter 1 puts that view in place by considering the limits of the distributive paradigm. Chapter 2, “Five Faces of Oppression”, develops a way of recognizing different forms of constraint. Community resources can be valuable remedies. To see what should change, one also has to understand how a constraint is produced.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!