Reason and domination › Can reason examine itself?
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Reason and domination › Can reason examine itself?Section view · Sections in this chapter6 / 7 ↓
A critic can ask how the authors are entitled to the distinction between good and bad uses of thought. The book itself uses reasoning to describe connections between practices, consider objections, and diagnose errors. If every rational operation were already an instance of domination, the criticism would have difficulty explaining why its conclusions deserve to be heard. The original preface gives one way of addressing that problem. It treats freedom as inseparable from enlightened thinking and says the work aims to prepare a positive concept of enlightenment that is capable of freeing itself from its ties to domination. The claim opens a task as much as it supplies an answer. How would one organize present practices so that their purposes remain open to examination? Dialectic of Enlightenment, original preface, pp. xiv–xviii.
Another criticism concerns the scale of the history. Connecting mythical fate, exchange, industrial entertainment, and persecution can reveal a recurrent way of imposing an order. It can also make differences between the cases hard to see. A comparison needs to give grounds for finding a feature in common and identify where the analogy breaks. An account of the entertainment business needs evidence about organization and access. An account of oppression needs a history of the particular powers and people involved. The authors themselves declined in the 1969 preface to stand by every formulation from the earlier period. That leaves room to take their questions seriously while asking which answers survive changes in the institutions they examined. Dialectic of Enlightenment, preface to the 1969 edition, pp. xi–xii.
The 1969 preface also distinguishes historical criticism from a verdict that assumes the same diagnosis must remain right at every date. A claim about how broadcasting, ownership, and reception were organized during the authors’ period can be tested against what those organizations made possible. It can then be applied to a later case only if enough of the relationships are still present. This restriction leaves the reader with a more specific inquiry than asking whether modern culture is better or worse. It asks which industrial practices allow an audience to do something with a work, and which allow the industry to anticipate that response and sell it back. Dialectic of Enlightenment, preface to the 1969 edition and “The Culture Industry”.
Go back to the ship after the Sirens can no longer be heard. The plan did what it was designed to do. The rowers brought the crew past the danger and Odysseus survived what he heard. A fuller assessment can also ask whose reasons were taken into account, who worked, and what it took to make the arrangement hold. Horkheimer and Adorno use enlightenment's genuine successes to raise questions that the measures of those successes can leave untouched.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!