Understanding totalitarian domination › Antisemitism and Imperialism as Political Problems
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Understanding totalitarian domination › Antisemitism and Imperialism as Political ProblemsSection view · Sections in this chapter2 / 7 ↓
In the first part Arendt distinguishes modern political antisemitism from the history of religious hostility toward Jews. She examines the position of Jews in European nation-states alongside episodes in which a political movement could treat Jews as the explanation for conflicts they had not created. Her treatment of the Dreyfus affair follows struggles in and around the French army, the press, the courts and public politics. A political account needs to say how the accusation worked and who gave it consequence. The existence of prejudice can help explain why an accusation finds an audience. We still need to ask how people gain the means to turn that accusation into an organizing principle. Origins, Part One, chapters I–II and IV
The distinction does not make hostility less serious. It identifies a different question about what political institutions can do with it. Consider an official inquiry that is formally open to evidence but treats the accused person's ancestry as grounds for discounting any defense. Other participants may challenge the prejudicial inference, appeal to safeguards of the institution or try to expose misconduct. Whether such responses are possible depends on whether people can put evidence into circulation and be heard in a setting that retains some independence. Arendt's later inquiry into total domination takes such possibilities seriously because a regime can attack them systematically.
In the second part, Arendt examines expansion pursued as a principle of imperial politics, then discusses forms of rule organized around race and bureaucracy. These chapters describe ways of governing people while withholding equal membership in the political community whose officials make the decisions. The subject of a bureaucratic decree can face great coercive power without having access to the forms of public contest available to some members of the ruling nation. Arendt connects this separation to the history of empire. To make sense of the connection, distinguish the interest in continuing expansion from the apparatus used to govern people subjected to it. Origins, Part Two, chapters V and VII
The connection invites a further historical question. Different colonial settings had different institutions and ways of organizing resistance, and the fact that a later regime used elements familiar from an empire leaves work to do. Which practices continued? Where were ideas or methods changed when they were taken up in Europe? The reader can ask for specific links rather than treating a similarity as proof of a necessary sequence. This is also a way to identify a limit of Arendt's comparison. Her account of elements that can combine will need particular histories to establish how they did.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!