Understanding totalitarian domination › Ideology, Terror and the Destruction of Initiative

Michael BrenndoerferUpdated October 27, 20263 min read
PhilosophyAll chapters
Reading tools Notes & comments
Notes & comments
Part 11 of 12Power, History, and Social Criticism
Chapter 130Understanding totalitarian domination › Ideology, Terror and the Destruction of Initiative
Reading section 5 of 7 · Ideology, Terror and the Destruction of Initiative · 3 minSection 5 of 7 · 3 min

Section 5 of 7 · 3 min read

Understanding totalitarian domination › Ideology, Terror and the Destruction of InitiativeSection view · Sections in this chapter5 / 7 ↓

In “Ideology and Terror,” Arendt links ideology to an attempt to deduce what happens from a single premise about a supposed law of nature or history. Events then appear as consequences of that premise. An unexpected event need have little force as an objection, because the ideology gives the movement a way to redescribe it so that it belongs in the same explanation. The movement can claim, for instance, that contrary testimony shows how skillfully its enemies hide. The pattern reduces the independence of experience by supplying in advance what an apparent counterexample has to mean. Origins, Part Three, chapter XIII

Terror gives that account institutional consequences. People can be treated as carriers of processes that the rulers take themselves to be enforcing. If the citizen's action has no bearing on whether they fall under a category that the regime has already determined to eliminate, it becomes difficult to change one's situation by appeal, explanation or cooperation with others. Arendt studies the camps as sites where domination attacks legal standing, the ability to make morally meaningful choices and the capacity to act spontaneously. The chapter is about what such a system seeks to do to people. The analysis leaves room to notice the actual variations and acts of resistance that a historical account would have to address. Origins, Part Three, chapters XII–XIII

That discussion identifies several disabilities which can come apart. First a person can be placed beyond the ordinary reach of a legal remedy. A second injury concerns the possibility of an action with a recognizable moral meaning. The regime can destroy the settings in which someone could bear witness or can present a prisoner with choices in which the people they protect are made to pay for the decision. Arendt then asks what happens to individuality and the ability to begin something. She distinguishes these targets so that a description of injury can go beyond naming the infliction of pain. The historical examples are extreme. They give her a way to specify the sort of domination her concept is supposed to pick out. Origins, Part Three, chapter XII, “Total Domination”

Arendt also separates political isolation from loneliness. Someone can be isolated because they cannot act with others and still keep certain relationships and a dependable sense of the world in private life. Loneliness, in the stronger sense she examines, concerns losing a reliable relation to others and to the world in which one's experiences could be tested. It also differs from solitude, in which a person can be alone and continue to think and return to others. These distinctions help explain why the destruction of independent associations and the fabrication of a coherent world can matter together. A movement can present its account as the one dependable orientation to people whose other points of reference have become precarious.

Suppose two neighbors each see a fact that counts against an official explanation. So long as they can talk freely and compare what they observed, each has a way to test whether they misunderstood an event. If discussion is dangerous and accessible records have been remade to fit the explanation, the exercise becomes harder. This example does not require assuming that belief is entirely dictated by institutions. It shows a concrete way in which independent judgment can depend on the conditions for sharing experience. The book asks us to understand how those conditions can be removed.

Comments

Add to the conversation

A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!

Newsletter

Stay up to date

Get new articles, book updates, and notes on AI and technology.

Unsubscribe at any time. Privacy policy