Understanding totalitarian domination › From a Movement to a System of Rule
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Understanding totalitarian domination › From a Movement to a System of RuleSection view · Sections in this chapter4 / 7 ↓
The third part examines how a movement can create a world for its supporters before and after taking power. Arendt describes propaganda as doing more than persuading people of particular falsehoods. A movement can make its claims seem consistent with members' everyday experience by organizing their surroundings accordingly. It can distribute positions and authority on the assumption that a doctrine is true. Members can then encounter roles and apparent confirmation that the organization itself has produced. Arendt treats that connection between propaganda and organization as important to how a movement gains and maintains loyalty. Origins, Part Three, chapter XI
For instance, imagine an organization that identifies an allegedly disloyal group in advance. Its records include every incident in which a member of the group drew official attention. Similar conduct by other people goes unrecorded. Looking at those records could seem to confirm the original classification. If officials begin to intervene solely on the basis of the classification, those interventions can fill the records with new entries. The example is ours. It shows what additional work organization does in Arendt's description. The claim becomes built into what people can reliably see when they consult the organization's records.
Once such a movement takes power, the relationship of propaganda to violence changes. Arendt asks what happens when rulers can reorganize institutions and remove much of the public space in which contrary experiences might be shared. In the chapter on totalitarian government she distinguishes the visible state from party power and discusses the role of the secret police. Shifting responsibility between offices can make it difficult to know who can decide a case or challenge an order. The uncertainty can itself increase dependence on the movement. The book analyzes this mutability of power and authority as part of government, alongside the pursuit and punishment of people selected as enemies. Origins, Part Three, chapter XII
A familiar authoritarian ruler may use violence to frighten people out of opposition. Arendt's account extends beyond that purpose. A category such as the objective enemy can make someone a target regardless of what they have done or intended. When the governing doctrine determines the target in advance, actual compliance and proof of personal innocence offer little defense. A comparison with a government seeking to repress identifiable opponents makes the distinction clearer. The latter can have a recognizable stopping point once resistance is suppressed. Arendt asks why the movement's terror can continue and find new targets after organized resistance has been crushed. Origins, Part Three, chapter XII, “The Secret Police”
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!