Art and reproduction › Authenticity and aura
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Art and reproduction › Authenticity and auraSection view · Sections in this chapter2 / 6 ↓
Benjamin asks what a reproduction can transmit. An old painting has a particular existence in time and space. Its materials have changed, and it has passed through a set of places and owners. In principle, one can ask which marks on its surface belong to which moment in that history. A reproduction can represent a mark accurately. It cannot have acquired that mark through the original’s sequence of events. In section II, Benjamin associates authenticity with the original’s physical duration and with its capacity to testify to its own history. A photograph can bring some of its features to us while leaving behind the material particulars that could give evidence about how they came to be there. Section II.
Aura connects this issue with a manner of perceiving. In section III Benjamin describes it through the relation of distance and nearness. His examples include following a mountain range with one’s eyes and looking at a branch that casts a shadow over the observer. A mountain has no workshop provenance to authenticate. It illustrates a sense of distance or distinctness that can belong to what one encounters even in its presence. With a work of art that experience can be connected to singularity, historical witness, and a tradition that gives the work a particular place. This connection is one part of the explanation of why the possibility of making the work present in many settings can alter someone’s relation to it. Sections II–IV.
The reproduction can also disclose things an unaided observer would miss. A camera can choose an angle or magnify a detail. It can make the image available in circumstances the original could never reach. Benjamin gives the example of a cathedral brought into a private setting by a reproduction. The changed situation is significant even if the image is poor and even if everyone knows where the original building stands. A photograph in a room can be inspected at the viewer’s convenience, compared with other photographs, and reused for different purposes. Such access differs from approaching a building in its physical surroundings and inheriting the conditions of visibility and use established there. Section II.
What Benjamin calls the withering of aura concerns the cumulative effect of such changes. He links reproduction to a wish to bring things close and to treat individually situated appearances as available in repeatable images. Consider the person comparing details on slides. They can place different objects side by side, leave out their surroundings, and move on to a different group of examples. These are real abilities. They also change the attention the setting asks of the viewer, what features seem salient, and how much authority comes from an object’s singular place in a tradition. That is the difference the concept of aura helps the essay describe. Sections II–III.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!