Art and reproduction › Film changes how a performance is made

Michael BrenndoerferUpdated February 3, 20263 min read
PhilosophyAll chapters
Reading tools Notes & comments
Notes & comments
Part 12 of 12Art, Beauty, and Interpretation
Chapter 140Art and reproduction › Film changes how a performance is made
Reading section 4 of 6 · Film changes how a performance is made · 3 minSection 4 of 6 · 3 min

Section 4 of 6 · 3 min read

Art and reproduction › Film changes how a performance is madeSection view · Sections in this chapter4 / 6 ↓

A film actor performs before equipment, frequently in separate takes and without the audience that will later see the performance. Benjamin contrasts this arrangement with an audience sharing the space and sequence of a stage actor’s performance. For a film, the jump out of a window and the ensuing flight can be shot in different places at different times. Those pieces become parts of a single event for viewers only through their later combination. A motion, expression, or sound can be selected with the final arrangement in mind. The director and camera can reposition the spectator’s view from one fragment to the next. Reproduction is therefore already involved in how the work is constructed. The question of making a faithful copy after the event concerns only one part of this technical arrangement. Sections VIII–IX.

There are also consequences for the performer. The image of a performance can be separated from the occasion and sent to people the actor never meets. In section X, Benjamin pairs that separation with the film industry’s promotion of a public personality. A star’s name and image become objects of attention positioned outside the individual performance. Benjamin treats the celebrity cult as a manufactured response to changes in the presence of the performer. The example complicates a one-way account of auras disappearing as cameras multiply. An institution can answer a changed form of experience with a new way of making personalities seem singular and valuable, and the commercial uses of that appearance need to be examined. Section X.

Film also changes what can be perceived. Someone can know how to reach for a spoon and still have little sense of what the hand does in the fractions of a second between reaching and grasping it. Benjamin says film can enlarge ordinary movements, slow them down, and isolate parts from the rest of a scene. He uses the phrase optical unconscious for what the camera reveals, drawing an analogy between what a camera can make visible and what psychoanalysis brings into account about motives outside usual awareness. The camera can reveal a shape in a familiar action and make it available to repeated inspection. That possibility depends on apparatus and selection. People see what a particular framing and timing enable them to see. Section XIII.

Benjamin’s comparison of the painter and the camera operator turns on how each can intervene in a scene. He likens the operator to a surgeon who works by entering into what the unaided observer encounters as a whole. A film crew can set the camera at different distances and make separate records of an action. The resulting sequence can look as though someone simply witnessed the whole in front of them. The look of unmediated access can itself be an achievement of production. Imagine a documentary that presents views from several sides of a factory floor. Its audience can learn things someone at any one workstation could scarcely see. The ordering of the views still determines which workers appear connected, which changes are made salient, and whether an interruption seems routine or exceptional. The increased access gives people reasons to pay attention to the sequence’s construction as well as to what it shows. Section XI.

Comments

Add to the conversation

A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!

Newsletter

Stay up to date

Get new articles, book updates, and notes on AI and technology.

Unsubscribe at any time. Privacy policy