Art and reproduction › Cult value and exhibition value
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Art and reproduction › Cult value and exhibition valueSection view · Sections in this chapter3 / 6 ↓
Benjamin distinguishes two emphases in how a work is valued. Cult value is tied to the part it plays in ritual. He points to works whose effective presence matters even when the work is concealed, as in the case of sacred objects kept from general view. Exhibition value concerns the opportunities to make the work available to viewers. A bust that can be sent elsewhere can be exhibited under more circumstances than a statue fixed within a temple. A reproduction can extend these opportunities further. Benjamin claims that sufficiently large changes in exhibition possibilities also change what a work does socially. A work made in anticipation of broad exhibition meets a different practical demand from an object whose restricted access is part of its use. Sections IV–V.
The distinction runs through the medium of photography itself. In section VI, Benjamin sees a continuing role for cult value in early photographic portraits kept in remembrance of people who were absent or dead. A process that permits wider exhibition can also furnish an object with a place in a private practice of memory. He then turns to Eugène Atget’s photographs of Paris streets. Benjamin likens these pictures to photographs of the scene of a crime and treats them as possible historical evidence, to be read with an orientation different from that of a viewer lingering before a portrait. He connects this change to the importance of captions and, later, to the way one film shot prepares how a viewer reads another. Section VI.
The two kinds of value tell us what to look for in a case. A family can keep a photograph in a place from which visitors rarely see it. The very same technology can allow another photograph to address a large public with a caption that guides viewers toward a particular reading. The contrast concerns the organization of attention and use. When Benjamin writes that art acquires a basis in politics where its ritual basis recedes, the question becomes what institutions, purposes, and publics now determine how works are made and seen. His preface makes clear that those questions concern the conditions of production as well as the feelings of the person looking. Preface and sections IV–VI.
Some examples call for care about what the original even is. Benjamin asks what it would mean to designate one print as authentic when many can be made from the same photographic negative. Contrast the question with the effort to establish whether a painted canvas is the one recorded in an artist’s inventory. In the second case the researcher is looking for an enduring material object that could have been present at a particular event. In the first, several prints could genuinely descend from the same negative. It makes sense to ask which was printed during the photographer’s lifetime, whether the photographer approved a crop, and which prints were exhibited in a particular place. These are answerable historical questions. They concern a different use of authenticity from requiring one print to be the original work through which the others must be understood. Section IV.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!