Making inference explicit › How Scope Changes an Inference
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Making inference explicit › How Scope Changes an InferenceSection view · Sections in this chapter6 / 8 ↓
Take a slightly longer claim. Every student admires some teacher who has advised a doctoral candidate. In the simple table, a marked cell established just one relationship, the student's admiration for the teacher. With the additional condition, we would need to know that the teacher in that cell really did advise someone. It can be a different candidate for each teacher. The order in which the sentence introduces its people determines which of those choices has to be held fixed when we test it.
The scope of a negation matters in the same way. Denying the longer claim requires finding a student for whom no admired teacher meets the advising condition. That student might still admire a teacher, and there might be many advisers among the teachers admired by other students. It would take a much stronger claim to say that no student admires any adviser. What makes the difference visible is the position of the denial relative to the claims about each student and at least one teacher.
This gives a more specific sense to Frege's comparison with a microscope. We can inspect one part of a complicated claim while keeping track of just the connections needed to test an inference. The formal translation makes choices about the meaning of the original. A correct derivation from that translation still leaves us the question of whether we understood the original sentence correctly.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!