Art and its historical forms › The symbolic form
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Art and its historical forms › The symbolic formSection view · Sections in this chapter2 / 5 ↓
In symbolic art as Hegel conceives it, the content seeks an appropriate form while the relation between the two remains indeterminate or disproportionate. A work may reach for an absolute significance by making a natural shape immense, strange, or difficult to interpret. The result can be more than an accidental mismatch between an accomplished artist and faulty materials. Hegel attributes the difficulty to the conception being expressed as well as to the form. Without a more determinate content, there is no obvious point at which a given shape can fully satisfy the demand placed on it. The disproportion can itself give a work its interest. Introduction, §8, second division and Development of the Ideal in the Special Forms of Art.
Hegel’s treatment of pyramids occurs in his discussion of architecture. He reads them as monumental enclosures that preserve something within them, the body of the deceased. The form has an observable and organized relation to what it houses. But the significance of the departed person is concentrated elsewhere than in the outward shape regarded on its own. The relationship between visible structure, preserved body, and what the building is for is part of Hegel’s explanation for placing such structures in a particular development of architecture. His chapter also distinguishes different Egyptian building practices. He uses the pyramid to bring a particular relation into focus. Part III, section I, chapter I, §3(b), “Housing for the Dead, Pyramids, etc.”.
This interpretation has a limit. A theory of form can describe the relationship between what a building displays and what it encloses. The claim that its makers experienced an inadequate conception of spirit would require an argument of a different kind. The people who used it may have found the separation of exterior, interior, and body appropriate to their practices. Hegel ranks modes of art by the place they occupy in his account of spirit, and that ranking shapes his description of the examples. A reader can use the distinction between enclosure and visible embodiment without turning it into a finding about the development of whole civilizations.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!