Art and its historical forms › What can a work of art show?

Michael BrenndoerferUpdated July 14, 20266 min read
PhilosophyAll chapters
Reading tools Notes & comments
Notes & comments
Part 12 of 12Art, Beauty, and Interpretation
Chapter 139Art and its historical forms › What can a work of art show?
Reading section 1 of 5 · What can a work of art show? · 6 minSection 1 of 5 · 6 min

Section 1 of 5 · 6 min read

Art and its historical forms › What can a work of art show?Section view · Sections in this chapter1 / 5 ↓

A statue and a statement can present very different accounts of courage. A statement can distinguish courage from recklessness or give reasons why someone’s action deserves the name. A statue can make an account of courage perceptible in the attitude of a body, in the balance of composure and readiness, and in the relation of the figure to the space around it. Replacing the statue with a sentence would preserve some of what a viewer understands and discard much of how the viewer comes to understand it. G. W. F. Hegel’s Lectures on Aesthetics begin from the importance of this kind of presentation. Art can disclose something about the world and about how people understand themselves by giving it a shape people can see, hear, or imagine. Introduction, §§1–2.

Hegel taught aesthetics in Heidelberg and on four occasions in Berlin. The familiar Lectures are a posthumous edition assembled by Heinrich Gustav Hotho from material that included a manuscript by Hegel and lecture transcripts. The first edition appeared in parts from 1835 to 1838. This chapter follows the arrangement familiar from that edition, chiefly in T. M. Knox’s English translation. The published arrangement is historically important in its own right. A claim about what Hegel told one particular audience would require evidence from the records of that course. Editorial history of the lectures and catalog record for the 1835 first volume.

Artistic beauty and appearance

In the introduction, Hegel identifies his subject as the philosophy of fine art and gives artistic beauty priority over natural beauty. He recognizes that ordinary speech calls rivers, flowers, and colors beautiful. A river can be admired for its appearance. In a painting of that river, someone has shaped what appears, placing the bank or the horizon in a relation to everything else the viewer can see. For Hegel the philosophical interest lies in such a work having been made through human activity and being able to give human significance a perceptible form. The introduction’s concern with artistic beauty follows from that interest. Later parts of the lectures examine natural beauty in developing the account of the ideal. Introduction, §§1–2 and 8.

The emphasis on appearance can sound at odds with the emphasis on truth. If a figure is made of stone, or a character’s suffering is enacted by a performer, an audience knows it is encountering a made thing. Hegel asks why an appearance made for reflection should therefore count as a deception. A play can bring a conflict into view by selecting and arranging episodes. In ordinary life those tensions might be hard to discern through accident, distraction, and the participant’s limited point of view. The crafted appearance gives the audience an opportunity to grasp the relation between things. It is part of how the work can bring its content into view. Introduction, §2.

This is where Hegel gives art a place alongside religion and philosophy. In the introduction, the three share a concern with what he calls the deepest truths of spirit. Their ways of making those truths available differ. Art presents them sensuously. Religion presents its content in the form of representation. Philosophy seeks to grasp it conceptually. Spirit here concerns the ways mind comes to know itself, including in shared forms of life and their works. Think of the difference between facing a statue in a temple and reading an account of which powers the divinity embodies. The viewer can understand something through the statue’s appearance and the setting in which it stands. A philosophical account can ask what makes such an understanding possible and whether the conception it reveals is adequate. Introduction, §2.

The lectures test this point against a famous story about Zeuxis. The painter was said to have depicted grapes convincingly enough that living birds tried to peck at them. That result gives one measure of success. Hegel asks why deceiving a bird should count as the highest achievement of art. The animal reacts to a painted surface as if it were food. It has no occasion to notice how a painter could arrange color, light, or other details to make a human concern clear. An artist who can create such an illusion may have remarkable skill. An account of what a work brings into view still has to inquire what the skill was used to do. A play’s power to let an audience understand conflicting obligations is a different accomplishment from its ability to make a room on the stage look enough like an ordinary room that someone mistakes it for one. Introduction, §6(iii).

When a form is right for its content

Hegel’s terms Idea and Ideal give a more specific account of artistic form. The content may be a distinct conception of the divine, freedom, or human action. Giving such content a suitable shape is a central task of art. Moreover, it matters how determinate the content already is. In the introduction’s discussion of the Ideal, Hegel distinguishes a representation that suits its particular content from the fuller artistic beauty he finds when a work embodies a content capable of that unity. A highly accurate image of an arbitrary object can suit its purpose. Natural accuracy alone leaves open what kind of significance is present in its appearance. Introduction, §8, first division.

The three art-forms arise in his analysis of that relation. Symbolic, classical, and romantic name different ways a spiritual content can inhabit its expression. Hegel associates them with historical developments and uses historical examples to argue for his ordering. The same terms describe relationships within particular works, so simple labels on a date chart miss a large part of the account. A Greek building and a Greek statue can give different weight to matter and figure. A later building can contain a sculpture and give space to a form of worship without giving all three a single artistic function. The distinction between art-forms and the individual arts becomes important as soon as we start looking closely at such cases. Introduction, §8, second and third divisions.

Comments

Add to the conversation

A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!

Newsletter

Stay up to date

Get new articles, book updates, and notes on AI and technology.

Unsubscribe at any time. Privacy policy