Normal science and conceptual change › How an Anomaly Becomes Important
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Normal science and conceptual change › How an Anomaly Becomes ImportantSection view · Sections in this chapter4 / 8 ↓
Well-developed expectations help make unexpected results recognizable. The laboratory in our example can identify a reading as a surprise because its methods and theory suggest an outcome. The researchers might spend days checking the settings and using a different batch of material. In Kuhn's account, this is ordinarily work on a puzzle. People have reason to explore a difficulty inside a framework that helps them recognize and solve others. The fact that one calculation or reading does not yet agree with the framework leaves open what the problem is and whether a small change will resolve it. The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, chs. VI and VIII
An anomaly can take on a different standing when attempts to explain it keep running into the same difficulty. Kuhn identifies cases in which a mismatch concerns a particularly important expectation or works against an established application. Repeatedly trying to solve that problem helps show just how much would have to change if the anomaly could not be accommodated. In a crisis, researchers may offer more competing articulations of their shared account. Confidence in some of its rules can loosen. The sequence leaves scope for several responses, including solving the problem with the existing framework or setting the difficulty aside for another generation. The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, chs. VII–VIII
Kuhn gives an account of discovery in which noticing an anomalous result is a beginning. Researchers have to work out what the result is a case of. He discusses oxygen to show how reporting that someone discovered a gas can compress several developments. Preparing a sample, being able to distinguish it from other gases, and giving it a place in an account of combustion are distinguishable achievements. Assigning discovery to a single moment depends on which of those tasks one decides the word should name. The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, ch. VI, oxygen episode
Kuhn contrasts Joseph Priestley's identification of the gas within the vocabulary of phlogiston with Antoine Lavoisier's role in a different theory of combustion. A person could observe some of the same features of the gas and still understand what the experiment had produced in a different way. Kuhn also says the discovery of oxygen was insufficient by itself to bring about the change in chemistry. Lavoisier already had reasons for questioning some of the established account. The episode illustrates how a novel result can be shaped by the expectations under which it was detected and then become part of a different set of expectations. The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, ch. VI, oxygen and changes in chemical theory
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!