Normal science and conceptual change › What Changes in a Revolution
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Normal science and conceptual change › What Changes in a RevolutionSection view · Sections in this chapter5 / 8 ↓
A scientific revolution, in Kuhn's account, changes the commitments that organize a research tradition. An alternative has to offer a way of working on problems as well as a response to a particular anomaly. Researchers can ask whether the alternative preserves results they have relied on, opens problems they can investigate, or makes sense of a difficulty that had been left hanging. In some episodes, a problem that had been crucial within the earlier framework becomes less pressing in the new one. The change can affect which questions help determine the success of the account. The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, chs. VIII–IX and XII–XIII
Consider Kuhn's distinction between discovering an error and accepting a replacement. If a community were to stop relying on its established way of doing the work because a serious case had gone badly, it would still need to decide what to do next. Kuhn argues that rejection of a paradigm in the episodes he studies involves considering a rival way of working. Deciding about the rival brings in its relation to the evidence as well as how it compares with the existing approach. The challenge to a theory and the availability of an alternative can matter at different points in the same investigation. The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, ch. VIII
Kuhn also considers whether a revolution can simply be described as a newer theory adding precision to the old one. For Newtonian and relativistic dynamics, he distinguishes recovering forms of equations under limiting conditions from keeping the same meanings for all the terms that occur in them. A relation that gives a successful approximation in some applications can be worth keeping. What the relation says about time, space, or mass may have to be read within the commitments of the account that gives it a place. For Kuhn, the mathematical relationship does not erase every change in the concepts the equations express. The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, ch. IX, discussion of Newtonian and relativistic dynamics
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!