Normal science and conceptual change › How Rivals Can Be Compared
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Normal science and conceptual change › How Rivals Can Be ComparedSection view · Sections in this chapter6 / 8 ↓
Kuhn's term incommensurability concerns difficulties in bringing rival frameworks under one measure. The difficulty can arise because researchers who use the same word put it to work in different networks of problems and solutions. It can also arise because shared standards leave room for differences in which results count most. One group may value an alternative for making a wider range of problems accessible. Another may value the precision achieved by the current approach in a particular set of cases. Both can point to scientific considerations while disagreeing about how much each should weigh. The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, chs. IX and XII, and 1969 postscript, §§2, 5
Lack of a single decision procedure leaves substantial work to do. Kuhn discusses what researchers can learn by trying to translate claims into a vocabulary another community uses. It may be necessary to use a description longer than the term it was meant to replace, and the difference itself can be informative. He mentions the dispute between Joseph Louis Proust and Claude Louis Berthollet as a case in which reasoning across vocabularies could require avoiding the shared word element. Working through such a description can help an investigator see how someone else came to take a result as evidence or regard a particular sentence as an explanation. The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, 1969 postscript, §5, discussion of translation
This also gives a reader a way to understand disagreement about standards. Suppose one account can handle results from more experiments, while another offers very close quantitative agreement in a well-established range. Choosing what to investigate next requires attending to both achievements and to what the research community could learn by pursuing either one. If later results show that the first account's wider scope can come with the precision formerly achieved by the second, the practical balance changes. Kuhn's point is that the role of a shared value such as precision has to be seen in the particular argument over how a theory meets it. An agreed list of values does not supply a guaranteed result of the comparison. The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, 1969 postscript, §§2, 5
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!