Evaluating a research programme › A Test Puts Several Claims at Risk
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Evaluating a research programme › A Test Puts Several Claims at RiskSection view · Sections in this chapter2 / 7 ↓
A familiar argument begins with a theory and a prediction that follows from it. If the prediction fails, something in the reasoning that produced it or in the premises ascribed to that situation has to give way. A real test, however, also relies on claims about the case to which it is applied. In the orbital example, the result of a calculation depends on which bodies are included, their starting positions, and the treatment of relevant forces. The report from the telescope depends on how measurements were made and interpreted. A contradiction limits what the participants can consistently accept together. It may leave room for several choices about what to revise. Lakatos, “Falsification,” §§2(b)–(c)
This is one reason Lakatos distinguishes dogmatic falsification from more sophisticated positions. The dogmatic approach expects evidence to provide a verdict that can conclusively disprove a theory. He also discusses versions of methodological falsification that accept the fallibility of reports and make decisions about which observations and background theories to use in a particular test. He builds on that recognition. His proposal is to judge a failed theory in relation to alternatives that can preserve some of its successful work, make further commitments, and put those commitments to a test. Lakatos, “Falsification,” §§2(a)–(c)
Consider a simpler case. A laboratory predicts that a liquid will change color in a sealed container at a specified temperature. The change does not appear. A researcher can still question the calibration of the thermometer, the seal, the exact composition of the liquid, or the predicted threshold. Carrying out another test requires treating some of those issues as settled for the time being. Retaining a familiar theory during the next investigation can be reasonable if the investigators know which checks would bear on the alternatives. It would be a different kind of decision to declare from the outset that every conceivable result would be compatible with the theory, whatever else had to change. Lakatos, “Falsification,” §§2(c), 3(a)
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!