Evaluating a research programme › What Can Be Decided at the Time?

Michael BrenndoerferUpdated June 30, 20253 min read
PhilosophyAll chapters
Reading tools Notes & comments
Notes & comments
Part 9 of 12Science and Explanation
Chapter 113Evaluating a research programme › What Can Be Decided at the Time?
Reading section 5 of 7 · What Can Be Decided at the Time? · 3 minSection 5 of 7 · 3 min

Section 5 of 7 · 3 min read

Evaluating a research programme › What Can Be Decided at the Time?Section view · Sections in this chapter5 / 7 ↓

Some scientific results acquire much of their significance later. Lakatos discusses the motion of Mercury's perihelion, the point of the orbit closest to the Sun. Its anomalous motion was already a difficulty in the Newtonian programme. In Lakatos's presentation, Einstein's success in accounting for the discrepancy gave the earlier observation a new role in comparing programmes. The observation did not change in the meantime. What changed was what people could use it to discriminate between, because another theory was available and had enough structure to account for it. Lakatos, “Falsification,” §3(d), Mercury discussion

It follows that comparing programmes takes time. People have to develop the rival account, see what it preserves, and pursue observations that bear on its additional claims. An experiment can help settle which of two specific predictions should be accepted under given conditions. Whether it is a decisive episode in the history of two programmes may depend on other work, some of it still to be done. Lakatos uses the term instant rationality for the expectation that a single result or rule can immediately give a final verdict on a developing theory. He thinks the history of work on competing programmes makes a slower judgment more realistic. Lakatos, “Falsification,” §3(d)

In the meantime, researchers can identify where they are placing their bets. A group might keep working on a programme that has performed poorly lately because it has a definite proposal for making a test no rival has offered. A rival group might be already making successful predictions in cases the first group has found hard to reach. Comparing those situations can help someone decide where to spend their time. It cannot supply a deadline by which a programme has to recover. The method lets people ask whether working on it now amounts to pursuing a serious possibility or maintaining agreement with a familiar set of past results. The questions are more assessable than a rule that people must have the same verdict as soon as they see the same table of measurements. Lakatos, “Falsification,” §§3(c)–(d), 4

One challenge for the account is that an investigator choosing what to do has to act on a record that the historian will later know to be incomplete. The first group may have an idea that gives it a plausible research plan. There can be uncertainty about whether the idea is testable and will preserve enough of what scientists already know. The second group can point to tests it has passed, but the area where the two accounts differ most may not yet be accessible. Specifying what each side would count as progress can sharpen the disagreement before either gets to claim the result. It also leaves a written record of whether the hoped-for work eventually happened. Lakatos, “Falsification,” §3(d)

A new line of work may also begin inside a programme that has recently gone through a series of failures. Lakatos allows that a change in its positive heuristic can renew its prospects without replacing its core. That possibility gives its proponents a burden they can describe concretely. They have to show what the new direction will let them investigate and what findings would give reason to think it was productive. A former success may justify listening to their proposal. The evidence about whether the change worked will have to come from what the renewed programme can do. Lakatos, “Falsification,” §3(b)

Comments

Add to the conversation

A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!

Newsletter

Stay up to date

Get new articles, book updates, and notes on AI and technology.

Unsubscribe at any time. Privacy policy