Evaluating a research programme › Where the Programme Directs the Work
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Evaluating a research programme › Where the Programme Directs the WorkSection view · Sections in this chapter3 / 7 ↓
Lakatos calls the set of central commitments a programme holds fixed its hard core. In his example from the Newtonian programme, it includes the three laws of dynamics and the law of gravitation. Participants take disagreements with data as reasons to look initially at other parts of their explanation. Lakatos describes this protection as a methodological decision by the participants. The decision gives the programme a continuity across successive versions. It also means the outlook must prove what it can do through the changing theories that develop around the core. Lakatos, “Falsification,” §3(a)
The assumptions and initial conditions open to revision form a protective belt. Someone applying the laws of dynamics may have to decide which bodies to treat as isolated, which forces matter, and which detailed description to start with. If the predicted and observed paths differ, fixing one of those assumptions can be a good answer even when the laws are kept. The price of making that adjustment intelligible is to be explicit about which version of the combined explanation made the failed prediction and what the new version claims in its place. Lakatos, “Falsification,” §3(a)
There are two sides to the advice a programme gives. The negative heuristic specifies lines of revision to avoid. It can tell the researchers to reconsider auxiliary hypotheses when a result conflicts with a prediction. The positive heuristic suggests a direction in which to build these auxiliary theories. A group might begin with an idealized calculation and then work out how to include bodies that were initially treated as absent, or factors first left out to make the problem tractable. Having a reason to take the next model in that direction distinguishes a continuing programme from a set of changes with no relation beyond their arrival after a failure. Lakatos, “Falsification,” §§3(a)–(b)
The hard core identifies commitments participants hold fixed while developing a programme. The protective belt includes the auxiliary assumptions they can alter and test. The positive heuristic offers ways to develop those assumptions that can be considered before the next result comes in. Lakatos, “Falsification,” §§3(a)–(b)
The positive heuristic also helps explain how work can continue in the presence of known difficulties. An early model may be too restricted to answer a question its proponents already understand. They can pursue a more detailed version without needing an answer to every objection to the present one. What counts in favor of doing that is the prospect that the sequence will develop testable claims. The existence of a difficulty alone may tell us little about whether a proposed way of proceeding will yield a new result or just keep work occupied. Lakatos, “Falsification,” §3(b)
Lakatos gives the Newtonian series of models a particular role in illustrating those constraints. Modelling an orbit can begin with an intentionally simplified arrangement of bodies. The approximation directs attention to some of the strongest effects and leaves others to be introduced in more detailed cases. Lakatos describes a transition from simpler systems, with bodies treated as point masses or interacting in idealized ways, toward models that can take account of more of their properties and mutual effects. An idealization can guide this work even while its details become inappropriate at a later stage. He distinguishes the comparatively flexible way of building models from the central laws that this sequence of models is intended to put to work. Lakatos, “Falsification,” §3(b), Newtonian models and the flexibility of the positive heuristic
That distinction changes what you could learn from an objection to a model. If the early estimate assumes an isolated pair of bodies, finding that a third body influences the motion is a reason to reconsider the estimate. It also supplies a possible next step that a researcher could take without rewriting the basic equations. The estimate has done real work if it helps someone locate the discrepancy precisely enough to build the next model. It may remain serviceable in cases where the omitted effects are sufficiently small. Assessing it requires identifying the stage of the inquiry and what the people using it expected it to explain. Lakatos, “Falsification,” §3(b)
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!