Perception through a lived body › Testing the Account
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Perception through a lived body › Testing the AccountSection view · Sections in this chapter8 / 9 ↓
A useful objection is that the theory only gives a new name to skills we already knew existed. To answer it, ask what could distinguish two explanations of a particular action. An explicit map is useful when you can consult it and compare locations. Merleau-Ponty's examples concern cases where the practical significance of a place is already present in being able to move in relation to it. If calling both things a map leaves that difference out, the complaint has missed the explanatory purpose of the body schema. The term matters to the extent that it lets us articulate how practical and explicit knowledge can come apart.
Another objection is that skilled action is too narrow a basis for a theory of perception. Someone can perceive a strange object without knowing how to handle it. The cup example would prove too much if we concluded that every experience must offer a familiar action. But a strange object can be experienced from here, as partly hidden, or as something you would have to move closer to see. That leaves room for bodily orientation even when the eventual response is uncertain. The more demanding question is how particular kinds of experience depend on that orientation, and when another resource, such as deliberate interpretation, comes to the fore.
Try distinguishing three moments in an unfamiliar task. At first an instruction can make verbal sense without making the correct movement clear. With practice, features of the setting begin to indicate what to do. If the setting changes, you may need to make some of those features explicit again. Treat this as an exercise in description rather than a test from which to infer an unseen mechanism. The point is to notice what becomes evident with skill and what kinds of help are useful before the skill is available. That is the kind of observation for which Merleau-Ponty's account gives us a vocabulary.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!