Testing and falsification › How a Result Earns a Place in a Test
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Testing and falsification › How a Result Earns a Place in a TestSection view · Sections in this chapter4 / 7 ↓
A gauge that jumps suddenly might give you your first reason to think the valve stayed closed above the pressure limit. It could also be a bad gauge, an indication that the pressure was applied in an unanticipated way, or a sign that this valve is different from the model named in the claim. To continue, you would want to know whether you could describe what happened well enough for somebody else to check it. A statement that identifies the apparatus, relevant conditions, and observed result gives other people a point at which to challenge or extend the test. The Logic of Scientific Discovery, §§7–8, 22
Popper calls certain singular test statements basic statements. A basic statement may function as a premise from which a theoretical claim can be challenged. Its role as a premise does not give it permanent authority. Other people can dispute which gauge was used, repeat the test, or ask whether the apparent failure can be checked by a different measurement. In §22 Popper says that accepting some basic statements incompatible with a theory is necessary for regarding it as falsified. He also asks for a reproducible effect described by a testable, corroborated falsifying hypothesis. An unusual reading that cannot be reproduced can prompt a search without settling how that search will end. The Logic of Scientific Discovery, §§22, 25–30 · §22 teaching excerpt
This leaves a practical issue. If every statement in the test can itself be questioned, do people have to settle all such questions before they can do anything with the result? Popper says that a particular test stops where investigators decide their accepted statements are sufficient for its purposes. They can later ask more of them. He compares the situation to supporting a structure with piles driven into a swamp. The piles can support the building without having encountered an absolutely firm bottom. Finding a good enough point to stop is part of conducting a test, and no decision about it needs to preclude further testing. The Logic of Scientific Discovery, §30 and 1972 addendum
A result can therefore bear different weights at different stages of inquiry. Suppose the first run gives a puzzling pressure reading. A second lab measures the valve travel using a separate device and reproduces the effect. That tells you something more than the second lab's willingness to trust the first result. It gives the proposed description a chance to fail in a new setting. It might also show where the failure can be made to appear reliably. Working out which conditions produce the effect is already a small empirical inquiry of its own. The Logic of Scientific Discovery, §§22, 29–30
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!