The project of grounding mathematics in logic › The Problem With Unrestricted Collections
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
The project of grounding mathematics in logic › The Problem With Unrestricted CollectionsSection view · Sections in this chapter2 / 9 ↓
In the Introduction to Volume I, chapter II, Whitehead and Russell present contradictions that involve treating a domain as a completed totality. A familiar version starts with the proposed class of all classes that are not members of themselves. Call this proposed class R. If R is a member of itself, then it has the defining property required of its members, so it is not a member of itself. If it is not a member of itself, it satisfies the condition and is a member. The two conclusions come from applying the condition to the same thing the condition was used to specify.
This problem mattered to the proposed foundations of arithmetic because the earlier Fregean project relied on a general provision for extensions or courses of values. In Frege's reply to Russell in 1902, he identifies Rule V of his Basic Laws of Arithmetic as being in trouble. One direction of that law takes agreement of functions at every argument to guarantee identity of their courses of values. The familiar class formulation gives the contradiction an accessible shape. It is a way to see the trouble, rather than an account of every step in Frege's original formal notation.
Whitehead and Russell give a broader diagnosis. In their account of the vicious-circle principle, the offending constructions involve an apparent totality whose own members would be specifiable only by using the same totality. Their concern is visible even in the idea of a proposition about literally all propositions. If the proposition produced by taking that totality is itself one of its members, we need to ask how the totality was fixed in order to formulate the proposition. The principle directs the construction of their hierarchy.
The conventional example about R helps distinguish two tactics. One could accept an unrestricted language and try to devise a theorem saying that some classes do not exist. In Principia, the prior question is whether the proposed expression has been formed within an admissible range of arguments. The rules governing expressions matter before there is a proposition about R to prove or disprove.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!