The project of grounding mathematics in logic › What Class Talk Is For
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
The project of grounding mathematics in logic › What Class Talk Is ForSection view · Sections in this chapter4 / 9 ↓
Chapter III of the Introduction gives a different side of the response. The authors treat descriptions and class expressions as incomplete symbols. Their contribution is explained through rules for whole sentences in which they occur. This gives the reader something to do with a statement that appears to name a special kind of object. Look at the whole statement and see how the expression can be eliminated.
The account of descriptions is a useful example. Imagine that a committee has appointed nobody as treasurer. The sentence “the committee's treasurer signed the letter” sounds as if it starts by naming an officeholder and then adds a claim about what that person did. On the analysis in the Introduction, an ordinary use of the sentence requires that exactly one person meets the description and that this person signed. If no one meets the description, there is no need to identify some special object referred to by the phrase. The conditions on the whole assertion already explain why it fails.
Class expressions receive a corresponding treatment. An expression for the class of things satisfying a condition can occur in mathematical sentences that can be analyzed using propositional functions. What matters in an extensional use is which arguments satisfy the function. Two functions that agree on all appropriate arguments can therefore support the same class talk. Eliminating a class expression in this way gives the calculus the mathematical uses of class language without simply adding a new object for every apparent class name. Whitehead and Russell distinguish accomplishing that technical purpose from proving that, as a matter of metaphysics, there could be no classes.
The tradeoff is visible when the role of an expression changes. A sentence may be about the condition a function expresses, or it may be concerned only with the things satisfying it. The analysis of class talk needs the second kind of use. A condition such as “has three sides” can matter to an explanation for reasons beyond the bare fact that the very same figures also satisfy “has three angles.” Class language lets the system use the agreement in application without requiring the two explanations to have the same content.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!