Doing things by speaking › The Core Insight: Words That Act
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Doing things by speaking › The Core Insight: Words That ActSection view · Sections in this chapter3 / 9 ↓
Austin introduces the term performative through cases where uttering the words can be the performance of an action, as with naming the ship. The verb in an explicit form such as “I promise” helps state its own force. Promises can also be made without using that verb, and every occurrence of the formula need not be a promise. If I recite it as a line in a play, no commitment to repay you on Friday follows from my reading it. Austin, lecture I, pp. 5–7, and lecture VI.
Austin initially introduces performatives as utterances that are evaluated for how well their action is performed. Constatives are introduced by their role in stating how things stand. The later lectures ask how much these ways of evaluating speech overlap.
His first move was to draw a careful distinction between two kinds of utterances, a distinction he later abandoned as too simple but which remains a useful entry point. On one side we have constatives: statements that describe the world and can be true or false. On the other side we have performatives: utterances that perform an action and that, rather than being true or false, are subject to a different kind of evaluation, whether they succeed or fail, are appropriate or inappropriate, genuine or hollow.
Consider saying the familiar marriage formula as part of a ceremony. Austin stipulates that an accepted procedure is in place and that circumstances have to be right for the formula to do its work. An unauthorized bystander might imitate the words perfectly without producing the ceremony’s intended effect. A participant might also give the required answer insincerely. The difference matters: where standing is absent the act can misfire, while some defects concern the way a successfully invoked procedure was used. Austin, lectures I–II.
The first lectures ask whether looking at these failures gives us a cleaner test than grammatical form. Imagine hearing “I bet you that the horse will win” after the race is over. The timing can prevent it from counting as a bet of the intended kind. Compare a bet made in time and in a way the other person accepts, but made on a horse that loses. What first looked like the same result, the speaker was wrong, includes importantly different ways for things to go badly. Austin, lecture II, pp. 13–18.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!