Meaning and verification › Putting the Test on the Table
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Meaning and verification › Putting the Test on the TableSection view · Sections in this chapter7 / 8 ↓
Ayer's procedure helps a reader ask what kind of agreement a sentence is seeking. The report that a packet arrived calls for evidence about an event. The claim that there are five pairs in front of you can be checked by looking and counting, while the arithmetic used to describe the count has a different basis. A criticism of someone who hid the packet can express disapproval even when nobody disputes what happened. Separating these functions can expose cases in which people appear to argue about one thing while relying on different uses of the sentence.
The proposal itself gives rise to a different question. What gives a criterion of literal meaning its authority? Applying it to an ordinary report is simpler than explaining why all putative factual discourse should answer to it. Treating the criterion as a proposal about how to use literal significance would place it in a different role from the reports it is meant to sort. But a philosopher who makes that move still owes an account of why this proposal serves as a good boundary, and why it should disqualify the disputed cases. The ability to identify how a particular observation bears on a particular sentence is one result. The success of a single rule for every candidate statement is a further result, and the second-edition revision shows how much more would have to be demonstrated. Language, Truth and Logic, second-edition introduction
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!