Meaning and verification › What Ethical Language Does
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Meaning and verification › What Ethical Language DoesSection view · Sections in this chapter6 / 8 ↓
Ayer's separation of factual meaning from other uses of language gives the book's discussion of ethics a particular shape. He compares accusing someone of stealing money with accusing them of acting wrongly in stealing it. The occurrence of the theft can be a factual issue. Calling it wrong expresses moral disapproval on his account. He takes the ethical expression to do work in what we say to one another while adding no separate factual assertion to the accusation. Language, Truth and Logic, ch. VI, example of the theft accusation
Compare that use with saying that a speaker disapproves of what happened. The latter can be a factual claim about the speaker, which could turn out to be false if the person was acting or joking. To express disapproval is to use language in a different way. In the original accusation, a tone of anger can show an attitude without the speaker making a claim about their own state of mind. Ayer also says that ethical wording can be used to arouse feelings and encourage action. The way he discusses truth-telling brings the point out. An ethical expression can carry something of the force of a command or suggestion. Language, Truth and Logic, ch. VI, discussion of disapproval and commands
There is still room for argument about facts that people take to bear on their ethical judgments. Two people may initially disagree about whether a person should return the money. One thinks the cash was stolen. The other thinks a lender received it back. Checking the history could change the dispute. Ayer's harder case occurs when the parties agree on the description and still take different ethical positions. His account separates the dispute about the events from the clash of ethical attitudes. That brings into view a question an opponent can press. If someone offers reasons for reconsidering which kinds of action deserve disapproval, how much of that reasoning can be represented as a dispute about the facts alone? Language, Truth and Logic, ch. VI, discussion of whether ethical disputes are possible
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!