Meaning and verification › Reworking the Criterion

Michael BrenndoerferNovember 1, 20263 min read
PhilosophyAll chapters
Reading tools Notes & comments
Notes & comments
Part 9 of 12Science and Explanation
Chapter 110Meaning and verification › Reworking the Criterion
Reading section 5 of 8 · Reworking the Criterion · 3 minSection 5 of 8 · 3 min

Section 5 of 8 · 3 min read

Meaning and verification › Reworking the CriterionSection view · Sections in this chapter5 / 8 ↓

Weak verification leaves open a problem about what size of contribution a statement must make to the evidence. You can take a sentence that gives you no procedure for finding out whether it is true and join it to a claim that plainly does. Suppose someone says both that a stone left in the sun will warm and that the Absolute is content. The conjunction leads to the expectation about the stone. The second conjunct has done nothing to produce that expectation. The example shows why merely being able to obtain an observational consequence from a collection of statements is an insufficient test of each member of the collection. Language, Truth and Logic, second-edition introduction

Ayer's later formulation distinguishes direct and indirect verifiability. Direct verification covers observation statements themselves, as well as statements that yield an observation statement when combined with other observation statements that would not yield it on their own. An indirectly verifiable statement, together with admissible premises, must yield a directly verifiable statement that those premises alone do not yield. The admissible premises have to be analytic, directly verifiable, or independently established as indirectly verifiable. Ayer is trying to ensure that a statement under examination genuinely adds something while allowing other claims to help connect it to observation. Language, Truth and Logic, second-edition introduction, direct and indirect verification

Consider a claim about a pressure difference inside a sealed piece of equipment. The description can concern something you cannot make out by looking directly at the equipment. If a gauge works as specified, a given pressure difference could give its needle a reading that would otherwise be unexplained. The connection depends on other premises about the gauge and the setup. Those premises need a basis of their own for the arrangement to provide a meaningful check. Ayer makes room for theories stated in terms that do not directly name observable things by allowing the connections to run through separately warranted premises. The gauge is an illustration of why that allowance matters. Language, Truth and Logic, second-edition introduction, discussion of unobservable theoretical terms

Tightening the rules about the other premises does not by itself show that the test rules out every arbitrary claim. In his review of the second edition, Alonzo Church constructed a logical objection to Ayer's revision. Using observation statements and an arbitrary statement, he showed how combinations could meet the test in a way that lets that statement or its negation through. The point depends on the exact rules for entailment in the revised version. It illustrates the danger in judging factual significance by the logical arrangements into which a statement can be put. How a sentence contributes to a real investigation may be harder to capture than which formulas it can help entail. Church’s review, bibliographic record · Jeff Speaks, reconstruction of the formal objection

Comments

Add to the conversation

A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!

Newsletter

Stay up to date

Get new articles, book updates, and notes on AI and technology.

Unsubscribe at any time. Privacy policy