Writing and the idea of an original meaning › Trace and Writing in the Broader Sense
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Writing and the idea of an original meaning › Trace and Writing in the Broader SenseSection view · Sections in this chapter4 / 7 ↓
The book uses writing in a broader sense than marks made on a surface. Derrida introduces arche-writing when he asks about conditions shared by graphic and nongraphic expression. Because those conditions are supposed to be at work in the production of significant differences, they could not be identified with a first written message that preceded all speech. They belong to what makes a linguistic system possible, as distinct from the objects such a system contains. Of Grammatology, Part I, “Linguistics and Grammatology,” discussion of arche-writing and Hjelmslev
A single instruction uses contrasts that remain available even when their alternatives are unsaid. The word other in the note depends on a contrast with some door already understood to be under discussion. Seen by a person who did not read the earlier message, it still calls for that relation. This gives a modest example of a sign taking part of its sense from something absent. Derrida's use of trace makes a wider claim. A relation to what is other helps constitute what can presently appear as meaningful in the first place. An absent term need not be a bit of fully formed meaning that we merely discover was left behind. The current sign depends on a structure through which the distinction becomes possible. Of Grammatology, Part I, “Linguistics and Grammatology,” discussion of trace and the origin
A trace names the way what is absent or other can participate in making a sign intelligible. The trace matters to what can appear as present. It is more than a physical mark left behind after a meaning has been established. Of Grammatology, Part I, discussion of the trace
This also explains the change of scale involved in Derrida's vocabulary. A handwritten note makes it easy to see that the same words can work when their author is away. Observations of that kind give the reader a route into the argument. Calling the more general structure writing puts pressure on the hierarchy that reserves the name of writing for a secondary practice. An account of the broader structure still has to recognize the differences between handing someone a note and speaking to them face to face. An example can illustrate a condition they share without erasing what each medium allows people to do. Of Grammatology, Part I, discussion of arche-writing
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!