Writing and the idea of an original meaning › What a Supplement Reveals
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Writing and the idea of an original meaning › What a Supplement RevealsSection view · Sections in this chapter5 / 7 ↓
Derrida turns to Rousseau for a case in which writing can be dismissed as an addition and acknowledged as necessary in the same discussion. Rousseau values the proximity of thought and speech and treats a written representation as something added to it. The addition can be dangerous because the representation may take the place of a voice that is absent. Its danger and its utility are related. The written substitute can do something in a situation in which the speech itself is unavailable. Of Grammatology, Part II, “That Dangerous Supplement”
The word supplement covers two roles. A supplement can add to something already considered complete. It can also stand in for something missing. Consider a printed cast list for a play. It looks like an optional addition to the performance. If the production depends on the list to identify characters that nobody names onstage, the reader discovers a missing piece of information that the addition supplies. In Rousseau's case, Derrida wants to see how the two roles remain in contact. What looks like merely extra material can fill a lack, making it possible to ask what was complete about the thing to which it was added. Of Grammatology, Part II, “That Dangerous Supplement,” the two senses of the supplement
It would be too quick to infer that every useful addition reveals a fundamental defect. The cast list only bears on particular information about this play. A production in which every character readily identifies themselves may use a program for other reasons. Reading for a supplement involves identifying the work performed by a specific addition in a particular account. Derrida follows a recurrence in Rousseau, where the sign is said to threaten the presence it also has a role in restoring. That pairing is what makes the reading depend on Rousseau's words and distinctions, rather than on the general observation that people often use substitutes. Of Grammatology, Part II, “That Dangerous Supplement”
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!